Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Thu93 2020

Last update18:06 PM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
:: Opinions > Other Opinions
No Democracy For You!
Condoleezza Rice’s visit to Egypt this week was notable for what she said and who she met, but more notable for what she didn’t say and whom she didn’t meet. While it was remarkable to hear an American Secretary of State essentially
Wednesday, October 4,2006 00:00
by Hooman Majd, HuffingtonPost

Condoleezza Rice’s visit to Egypt this week was notable for what she said and who she met, but more notable for what she didn’t say and whom she didn’t meet. While it was remarkable to hear an American Secretary of State essentially apologize for years of American indifference to democracy in the region, her statements at once rang hollow because she neglected to meet with the Muslim Brotherhood, Egypt’s largest political opposition group, and Kifaya, Egypt’s second largest political group refused to meet with her.

Ms. Rice’s explanation of why she won’t talk to the Brotherhood? "Egypt has its laws, it has its rule of law, and I’ll respect that", she said. Right, like laws banning political parties. The Muslim Brotherhood is banned in Egypt, and its members face jail, torture and death. Although what they envision, an Islamic republic in Egypt under Sharia law, may be unappetizing to us, ignoring them or proclaiming them a terrorist-friendly party wins us no friends amongst the very people we are trying to engage in the region. The Muslim Brotherhood has renounced violence and hasn’t committed a terrorist act since the 1950s (although they do support Palestinian resistance and sympathize with the Iraqi insurgency), and Kifaya, a secular group, objects to foreign interference in general and American support for President Hosni Mubarak in particular. Kifaya’s boycott of a meeting Ms. Rice held in Cairo with Egyptian opposition leaders is a bigger slap in the face than our government (or our media) would like to admit. And what did Ms. Rice neglect to say? She didn’t say to President Mubarak that unless he allows free, truly free elections, America can’t possibly maintain the level of U.S. aid to Egypt (second-largest recipient of U.S. cash, after Israel).

It’s nice to hear the Bush administration taking a cue from Jimmy Carter’s presidency. Carter, who rightly thought the U.S. could win no friends by supporting repressive regimes and whose call for democracy throughout the world pre-dated George Bush’s by almost thirty years, watched while the people of two nations, Nicaragua and Iran, took his words to heart and threw out two of the world’s most corrupt and dictatorial regimes. Neither result was happy for the U.S. and President Carter may have paid for his idealism at the ballot box, but his administration initially accepted the will of the people in both countries. Carter’s foreign policy proved that we can’t be picky if we call for democratic change: as much as we deplored the turn of events in Iran in 1979, particularly after U.S. hostages were taken, it’s good to remember that over ninety percent of Iranians voted for the Islamic Republic and Ayatollah Khomeini’s vision of a theocracy in a referendum that no one accused of being rigged. (Granted, it was a yes/no referendum that didn’t offer an alternative.) Condoleezza Rice, in her recent visit to Egypt, showed that the Bush administration, not unlike the Soup Nazi of Seinfeld fame, means to be picky. If you’re the Muslim Brotherhood you can be immensely popular and you can be big, but when you come to place your order, “No democracy for you!”

Other Topics:

Rice appeals for end to violence among Palestinian factions
San Diego Union Tribune - United States
Rice Urges Egypt To Lead Middle East Democratization
Washington File - Washington,DC,USA
Rice says US with establishment of Palestinian state
Kuwait News Agency - Kuwait
Rice seeks end to Palestinian violence
Houston Chronicle - United States
Rice’s Gaza challenge
Ha’aretz - Tel Aviv,Israel
Rice faces calls for progress in Mideast
Awareness Times News Briefs From Sierra Leone
Awareness Times - Freetown,Sierra Leone
Rice Seeks End To Palestinian Violence
Guardian Unlimited - UK
A visit with an agenda
Middle East North Africa Financial Network - Amman,Jordan
Iran focus of Rice Mideast visit
Middle East Times - Cairo,Egypt
Rice to meet Egypt’s president, 8 Arab foreign ministers in Cairo ...
International Herald Tribune - France
Full text of Tony Blair’s speech
The Australian - Sydney,Australia
Rice To Travel To Middle East For Peace Diplomacy
Playfuls.com - Targu Mures,Romania
Human Rights Council discusses reports on situation of human ...
ReliefWeb (press release) - Geneva,Switzerland
The good news about lying to Americans
Media Monitors Network - CA,USA
Rice could meet eight Arab counterparts in Cairo
Raw Story - Cambridge,MA,USA
Monthly News Calendar
Washington Post - United States
RICE: Interview With the Wall Street Journal Editorial Board
Ikhwanweb, London-UK
A War Plan for the Democrats
The National Interest Online - Washington,DC,USA
Rice heads to Mideast as Palestinians clash
Stuff.co.nz - Wellington,New Zealand
Rice will try to get Arab allies to join efforts against Iran
USA Today - USA
Rice: No memory of CIA warning of attack
Houston Chronicle - United States
State Department under Truman, on Zionism and Israel
Al-Jazeerah.info - Dalton,GA,USA

Posted in Other Opinions  
Related Articles