Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Thu93 2020

Last update18:06 PM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
Research and Commentary
Is There an Egyptian Nation?
Is There an Egyptian Nation?
The current protests aren't about the President Mohamed Morsi's power grab -- this fight is over something far more basic.
Wednesday, December 5,2012 09:36
by SHADI HAMID Foreign Policy

In the latest round of Egypt's current crisis -- once again pitting Islamists against non-Islamists demonstrators gathered at the presidential palace in Cairo to protest President Mohamed Morsi's stunning decision to claim authoritarian, albeit temporary powers and his subsequent moves to rush through a controversial constitution. In a grim reminder of the country's precarious state, police clashed with protesters and fired tear gas.

But this isn't really about Morsi and his surprise decree -- though to be sure, parts of the decree employ language straight out of Orwell and seem almost designed to provoke and polarize. However, neither the decree nor the draft constitution are quite as bad as Morsi's opponents insisted. The opposition's sometimes bizarre comparisons to Adolf Hitler, Benito Mussolini, the 1933 Enabling Act, and the French Revolution suggest a legitimate fury (and an intriguing fascination with fascism), but make little sense as historic analogies.

Morsi could have read his Friday shopping list on national television, and it might have made little difference. The decree, after all, was only the latest in what Morsi's opponents see as a long list of abuses. Egypt's "original" revolutionaries are one such group that blast the Brotherhood's compromises small and large with the old state bureaucracy, lamenting how their revolution was sacrificed on the altar of expediency and gradualism. And it is true that the Brotherhood-appointed leaders of the Ministry of the Interior, the military, and the intelligence apparatus include men who were complicit in some of the worst human rights abuses of the Hosni Mubarak era -- and have gone unpunished to this day.
tags: Morsi / Islamists / Constitution / Revolution / Human Rights / Mubarak
Posted in Research and Commentary , EGYPT  
Related Articles
Hossam Ghariani: Constituent Assembly and New Constitution Statistics Speak for Themselves
Legal Campaign Accuses Egypt Supreme Constitutional Court of Political Maneuvering
Katatni Hails Judiciary Decision to Supervise Referendum on Draft Constitution
Egypt VP Mahmoud Makki in Televised Interview Sunday, Draft Constitution Best for Egypt
Abdel-Maksoud: Constitutional Court Maneuvers to Use Media Pressure for Political Gains
Muslim Brotherhood: Completion of Draft Constitution a Giant Leap for Egypt Free Will
Judges for Egypt: Constitutional Court Plots to Demolish State
Final Internal Committee Vote on Egypt Draft Constitution Thursday
Erian: Morsi’s Constitutional Declaration Will Be Cancelled Within Weeks by New National Charter
Erian: Some Fear Democracy, the Constitution, Elections and the New Public Prosecutor
Mahsoub: Refusing to Let Egypt Move towards Stability with New Constitution is True Tyranny
Freedom and Justice Party Statement on Recent Constitutional Declaration
Yasser Ali: Constitutional Declaration Follows Proper Consultations; Targets Fair Trials