Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Tue927 2022

Last update02:07 AM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
:: Opinions > Other Opinions
Opinion: Don't fear the Muslim Brotherhood
Opinion: Don't fear the Muslim Brotherhood
Those stoking fears that the Islamic group will take power in Egypt don't know much about it.
Concerning Egypt: There is a meme taking root in the op-ed pages of power. "The Muslim Brotherhood is coming. Watch out!"
Wednesday, February 2,2011 20:25
by Michael Goldfarb Global Post

Concerning Egypt: There is a meme taking root in the op-ed pages of power. "The Muslim Brotherhood is coming. Watch out!"

I say, stop this meme! Kill it before it multiplies! Unfortunately, once an idea appears on the pages of the New York Times or Washington Post it may already have fatally infected people who actually make policy.

Yesterday, Richard Cohen wrote in The Washington Post, "The Muslim Brotherhood seems to be lying low. Is this a reflection of weakness or canniness? The Brotherhood remains the only well-organized institution in Egypt other than the military."  

Yossi Klein Halevi chimed in at the New York Times, that in Israel " ... the grim assumption is that it is just a matter of time before the only real opposition group in Egypt, the Islamist Muslim Brotherhood, takes power."

Meanwhile, in The Daily Beast, Geoffrey Wawro compares what is happening in Egypt to the Iranian revolution, warning its outcome could be oppression in the form of the Muslim Brotherhood.

So we know that a serious position has been staked out, even before the outcome of Egyptians' extraordinary expression of people power has reached its climax.

It is unlikely that those propagating the meme have ever actually spent time with the Muslim Brotherhood. I have, so let me put forward a counter theory about the its power.

Shortly after Sept. 11, 2001, I made the trek through Cairo's unimaginably gridlocked traffic to the headquarters of the Brotherhood to interview Essam al-Arian, sort of the CEO of the group. His calm assurance about his organization's place in Egyptian society and its political strength was impressive. For proof he offered the fact that so many of his members were in prison. The fear felt by the regime of President Hosni Mubarak toward the Brotherhood was a demonstration of their power within the society.

And the regime's fear was justified. A community center near the Brotherhood's headquarters provided social services beyond the capability of the corrupt Mubarak government. In some neighborhoods, the Brotherhood operated as an alternative government.

It was impossible not to feel respect for the organization's strengths and shudder at its anti-Semitism. At a madrassah I watched children about 7 or 8 years old memorize a hadith (a biographical story of Mohammad) in which the prophet outsmarts some Jews trying to trick him. It was only later in places like Saudi Arabia, Jordan and Iraq, that I learned that the group represented just one strand of Islamist thinking — and not even the most radical one.

Like Richard Cohen, Yossi Klein Halevi and most GlobalPost readers I have watched the Egyptian uprising from afar. Like most people with some experience of Egypt I was waiting to see what the Brothers would do and was surprised at how little they seemed to be involved with the demonstrations. On Friday I caught a glimpse of al-Arian walking with some of his members to Tahrir Square. He didn't look a decade older but he looked tired — and out of his depth.

The days went by and still no assertion of the Brotherhood's supposed power.  Yesterday, as hundreds of thousands convened in Tahrir Square, it became apparent that the high tide of Muslim Brotherhood-style Islamism might well have passed.

When I spent an hour with al-Arian a decade ago his movement had crested. It basked in the  reflected glory of the destruction of the World Trade Center. It is hard to convey the oscillating emotions of people in the Arab world about that event. Most people condemned it and yet the same people felt that America — an abstract concept — maybe had it coming.

I think the Brotherhood rode on that crest through the invasion of Iraq, which galvanized the Arab street against the United States and its partners, like Hosni Mubarak.

But the Iraq insurgency changed things. Most American news coverage focused on attacks on U.S. troops during that horrifying period from May 2004 through the surge in 2007. It was easy to forget that the overwhelming number of people killed were ordinary Muslims. And they weren't just innocent bystanders. Schoolteachers, doctors, lawyers and engineers, the best of civil society, were dragged away by people acting in the name of Allah. Their mutilated corpses proved that their murderers, dressed up as the party of God, had neither compassion nor mercy.

The bloodshed  caused a backlash against groups like the Brotherhood, which purports to speak in the name of Islam — as do the killers in Iraq, Pakistan, Afghanistan and those who mete out vigilante justice in Hamas-stan. This is not just true in Egypt. Deep questions are being asked within the Muslim community about the violent minority who are killing so many of their fellow Muslims in the name of Islam. At least that is my impression from speaking with Muslims in Britain, people who come from all over the Islamic world.

Another reason not to fear the Brotherhood is this: They have never had to play politics in a real political system. It was easy to become the leading opposition force when there were no real politics in Egypt. Organized in the street and in friendly mosques, the Brotherhood became the one viable organization where those dissatisfied with the regime could take a stand. If there had been many different parties, the brothers might have remained in the background.

One other force I learned about in Egypt a decade ago and was reminded of this week may trump the Muslim Brotherhood: Egyptian national pride. It is more powerful than Islam and it is unique among nationalisms. The faces in Tahrir Square are identical to those on monumental statues preserved in Cairo's Egyptian Museum, which houses King Tut's treasures, the mummies and the gargantuan relics of ancient temples. 5,000 years have gone by and the same nation is still living along the Nile. That's not the case in the country I come from or where I live now.

More than one Egyptian I spoke to in 2001 reminded me of the long connection of the people to the place.  "We are the first civilization" is a mantra in Egypt. For most people the pyramids are a tourist destination. For Egyptians they are an assertion of primacy. Every country has nationalistic feeling, but Egypt's is unique, because the evidence of the claim is visible through the haze at the edge of Cairo.

I was reminded of this when a young man marching toward Tahrir Square yesterday schooled a TV reporter on this history. The man had a neatly trimmed beard and already was developing the permanent bruise in the middle of his forehead that is the mark of Muslims who pray five times a day. Maybe he was a member of the Brotherhood, maybe not. But he was for certain a proud Egyptian.

Here's a new meme: Egyptian nationalism is the likely force to emerge from this glorious chaos, not the Muslim Brotherhood. Propagate it.


tags: Muslim Brotherhood / Egypt / Islamist / Al-Arian / Mubarak / Mubarak Regime / Egyptian Regime / Egyptian Government / MB Members / Saudi Arabia / Jordan / Iraq / Islamist / United States / Muslims / Pakistan / Afghanistan / Moderate Muslim Brotherhood / Moderate MB / New York Times / Washington Post / Opposition Group / Iranian Revolution / Essam al-Arian / Egyptian Society / Mubarak Government / Demonstrations / Tahrir Square / Islamic World / Political System / Nile / Day of Rage
Posted in Other Opinions  
Muslim Brotherhood Eward
Surely you jest, should you think that the Muslim Brotherhood, those of the Ikhwan, are peaceful! They were formed to be militant, trained to be militant, and have always been militant. When, not if, Mubarak is finally removed from power, in the vacuum created by his absence, the Muslim Brotherhood will step. And that will end Egyptian freedoms. The nation will become as Iran, some free and in power, the rest in subjugation. I hope I am wrong, but I think not! Freedom loving Egyptians beware! The Ikhwanweb are near.
Wednesday, February 2,2011 21:12
Necessity is the mother of all Inventions qig504
If somebody walks-in to your house, uninvited, and starts killing his way through! What are you expected to be doing!!. Hands up over your head and match to the eternity!. It is a universal human-right to stand and fight whenever you are threaten by a self appointed guest of dishonour. Forget the terrorist Huuhaa, and keep pushing the Intruder out of your house together with his local courtesans. Common sense says so.
Friday, February 18,2011 06:21
Related Articles
A talk with the Muslim Brotherhood's Ibrahim Munir
Muslim Brotherhood's Statement on MB International Networking Case
Differences Between the Muslim Brotherhood and Hard-Line Salafi Groups
Will the Muslim Brotherhood Take Over?
Update: WikiLeaks Cables On Muslim Brotherhood
The Winds of Change as the Muslim Brotherhood and El-Baradei Close Ranks
The Muslim Brotherhood Bows out Graciously
Muslim Brotherhood vows global campaign
Muslim Brotherhood loses out in Egypt's elections
Muslim Brotherhood's Statement on Rigging of Parliamentary Election
Muslim Brotherhood's Opinion in a Newsletter: MP Demands HEC to Effectively Oversee the Polls
Muslim Brotherhood to campaign for elections
Q&A with head of Muslim Brotherhood parliamentary bloc
Muslim Brotherhood say 154 members arrested in pre-election sweep
Egypt: Muslim Brotherhood right to enter election
Muslim Brotherhood expert discusses Maghreb Salafism
Contradictory accounts over Al-Azhar's ban on Muslim Brotherhood book
Islamic Studies Institute and SSI Ally to Stop Registering The Book “Witness to the Muslim Brotherhood”
The irrelevance of the international Muslim Brotherhood
Muslim Brotherhood pokes social networking with Ikhwanbook