Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Tue109 2018

Last update19:14 PM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
New History or a New Mirage
New History or a New Mirage
Echoing Edward Said, the legendary Palestinian scholar, Antoine Raffoul addresses the ambiguities of Israel’s "new historians" who, with the clear exception of Ilan Pappe, condemn the occupation but fail to question the legitimacy of the Zionist State. They denounce the 1967 borders but not those violated in 1948. For as long as their celebrated revision of Israeli history continues to evade this core issue, the "new historians" will continue to be part of the problem instead of contributing to the solution.
Monday, November 15,2010 16:09

A recent reading of an old article written by the late Edward Said, the well-known Palestinian author, writer and cultural critic, revealed a rare meeting in Paris to discuss the core issues of the Palestine/Israel conflict. The participants were Israel’s rising ‘new’ historians at the time (professor Ilan Pappe, Benni Morris, Itamar Rabinowitch and Zeev Sternhell) and their Palestinian counterparts (Elie Sanbar, Nur Masalha and Said himself).

In the article, Edward Said noted that during the informal discussions which took place, the Israeli side (with the rare exception of professor Pappe) spoke of ‘the need for detachment, critical distance and reflective calm’, while the Palestinian was ‘much more urgent, more severe and even emotional in its insistence on the need for a new history’.

Said’s article touched on the core subject of the meeting: the need to look at the history of the Palestinian/Israeli conflict from the Palestinian point of view and to bring to the fore the events that lead to the 1948 Palestinian Nakba. Despite the attempt by some of the Israeli historians to admit that ‘an injustice’ may have been committed by the Israelis in 1948, the belief amongst most of them was that it was ‘a necessary conquest’. Only professor Pappe spoke with powerful eloquence delivering, in Said’s words, ‘an espousal of the Palestinian point of view and…[providing] the most iconoclastic and brilliant of the Israeli interventions’.

Yes, the Israelis in Paris said, they wanted peace, but, no, they did not inflict the Nakba of 1948 on the Palestinians.

Again, Edward Said wrote, with the exception of professor Pappe, the rest of the Israeli team members, showed a ‘profound contradiction, bordering on schizophrenia that informs their work’. They seemed to hesitate ‘when pushed hard by either Pappe or by the Palestinians’.

The Paris meeting took place in early May 1998. The Oslo euphoria was still in the air and (hold your breath) Benyamin Netanyahu was enjoying his first term as Israel’s Prime Minister (1996-1999). Under him, Israel held all the Palestinian territories occupied by force in 1948, 1949 and 1967 (and for those who need a reminder, that’s ALL of historic Palestine); it had the most formidable military power in the region; it dictated all the rules of occupation on an occupied civilian population in the OPT and it had the luxury of time and space at its disposal.

Slow forward seven years to May 2005, when George W Bush was claiming the mantle of yet another failed peace process (on the back of his criminal invasion of Iraq and Afghanistan) and Sharon was bulldozing his way through the Palestinian Territories with his Apartheid Wall. Professor Pappe wrote a devastatingly insightful article entitled: "The Palestine Peace Process: Unlearned Lessons of History". This article echoed the failures of all the previous peace processes since Oslo, but, predictably, all later peace processes launched since his article was written. A lot of processes, it seems, and no peace.

JPEG - 21.8 kb
Professor Ilan Pappe: "Zionism is far more dangerous . . . than Islam."
("A Shared History, a Different Conclusion", by Scott Wilson, The Washington Post, March 11, 2007.)

In his article, professor Pappe, with the vision of a sharp historian, warned that ‘unless the US can now begin to pay attention to the lessons of history [read 1948], this new round of peace talks will not only end in failure, but the hopes currently aroused will turn once again into despair, fury and a renewed wave of violence and devastation’. We now know what happened to Bush and to his peace process.

Fast forward to the present day, November 2010, (twelve and a half years after the Paris meeting), and we have Benjamin Netanyahu again as Prime Minister, the illegal occupation of the OPT still continues with even more devastation across the whole landscape of Palestine, the Israeli military machine is pumped up by more nuclear arsenals and (hold your breath again) a new peace process launched by Barak Obama, the U.S President riding high (at the time of his election) on the biggest public support of any previous American president. Yet, no sooner had Obama’s peace process been launched than the quick sands of the Middle East began to swallow it without mercy. Across the Palestinian landscape, and especially in occupied East Jerusalem, more demolition of Palestinian homes, more confiscation of farms, olive groves and more outright property theft of private houses by right-wing Zionist settlers under the protection of Israeli law and its military machine take place as the international community watches helplessly.

What does this all show?

It confirms what we have always believed: that the Zionist project of occupying and holding on to all of historic Palestine was, is and continues to be the prime and sole objective of the Zionist leadership in Israel. For this to happen and in an effort to smooth the path infront of such a colonial juggernaut, Israeli media has been put to sleep and the Israeli military leadership was made the only news outlet spurting out the sanitized version of the news to an indifferent Israeli public.

Since the Paris meeting and since professor Pappe’s prophetic article, the only bright light shining out of Israel (and now out of the UK) remains professor Pappe’s consistent and brave call for a debate on the 1948 Nakba. The other ‘new historians’ who met in Paris, remain mysteriously silent and surprisingly elusive about this issue.

JPEG - 26.9 kb
Palestinian holds key and certirficate of registration from his original home during a Nakba rally in the West Bank city of Nablus; May 14, 2009.

It is clear to the informed reader and observer of the Israeli/Palestinian conflict that nothing will move on any future process to achieve a just and lasting peace in historic Palestine unless the 1948 Nakba, the Return of the Palestinian Refugees and rule of International Law have been embraced and made the basis for the next peace process.

Finally, it is also clear that the Zionist leaders occupying the Israeli Knesset have now become aware that their colonial juggernaut is running out of fuel. So, in order to pump more colonial life into it, they have come up with the racist “Oath to the Jewish Nation”. Its twin tank has been filled with the illegal call to punish all those who commemorate the 1948 Nakba.

A new mirage or a new reality?


tags: Nakba / 1948 / Palestinian People / Netanyahu / Bush / Iraq War / Afghanistan / Apartheid Wall / Peace Process / Middle East / Obama / Jerusalem / Palestinian Homes / Zionist Settlers / Israeli Settler / Israeli Settlement / Jewish Settler / IOA / IOF / Israeli Crimes / / Obama Administraition / Bush Administraition / Palestine-Israel Conflict / Oslo / Edward Said / 1967 / Jewish Settlement
Posted in Palestine  
Add Comment Send to Friend Print
Related Articles
Jewish settlers burn olive trees in Nablus
Zionist plan to build 130 new settlement units in occupied Jerusalem
Bush blames Mubarak for war decision
Obama renews vows to improve ties with Muslim world
Netanyahu's speech in N. America interrupted by pro-Palestinians
UN, EU concerned over Israeli settlement activity as more settlers pour in OJ
Israel's Jerusalem municipality announces new settlement projects in city
Big settlement projects approved as Netanyahu flies to US
UK foreign minister handed letter from Jerusalemite officials facing exile
Israel razes two Palestinian homes in Ara
Obama's Expanding War In Pakistan: Key to U.S. Withdrawal From Afghanistan
The Middle East's stagnant 'change'
Netanyahu in Washington next week, no meeting with Obama scheduled
Jewish settlers on the rampage in Salfit
Thousands of 1948 Palestinians commemorate the Kafr Qasem massacre
Wikileaks for dummies: exposing the Iraq war crimes files
Jewish settlers destroy 200 olive trees in Nablus
IOF orders demolition of Palestinian homes in Bethlehem, arrests 4 in Silwan
Iraq war logs: Apache Crew Killed Insurgents Who Tried to Surrender
Iraq War Logs: Secret Files Show How US Ignored Torture
Israel's Longstanding Middle East Plan
Israeli settlers set fire to more than 2,500 olive trees in Burin
Dr Linda Norgrove – victim of the UK’s Afghanistan policy
Zionist settlers burn olive fields, run over a youth
Zionist settlers drench Palestinian grapevines with sewage water
Syria’s “Four Seas” Policy and the New Middle East Quartet
Zionist settlers attack Palestinian farmers, hurt old man
What Obama Hasn't Changed About the Mid East Peace Process
Qiresh Family Eviction: 1948 Ethnic Cleansing Continues [must see]
Abbas is unfit to lead the Palestinian people
West Bank activists injured in protests against apartheid wall
Noam Chomsky: The Real Reasons the U.S. Enables Israeli Crimes and Atrocities
IOA rebuilds apartheid wall in central Lod
Haneyya: The Palestinian people not afraid of Israel's war threats
IOF troops demolish tens of Palestinian homes in Jordan Valley
Rise people, rise: call for zero tolerance of Israeli crimes
Bahar: IOA planning to get rid of Palestinians in 1948 occupied Palestine
Nakba-62: we will not forget, we will not forgive
Sit-in outside British gov’t building on Nakba anniversary
Erdogan: Aggression against Jerusalem hinders peace process
Can Obama erase ‘Bush nostalgia’ in the Middle East?
Hamas: Israel’s decision to expel West Bankers is a new Nakba
IOF disguised soldiers ambush four citizens, wound one
Mansi: Israeli settlement expansion with American blessing
Bahar: The Palestinian people in Gaza made heroic epics during the Israeli war
Farouq: Egypt keeps quiet when it comes to Israeli crimes and takes actions to punish Palestinians
UN: The Israeli apartheid wall has serious impacts on life of Palestinians
IOA distributes new demolition orders of Palestinian homes
IOA issues 17 demolition orders against Palestinian homes in OJ
An Opportunity to Revive the Peace Process