Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Thu93 2020

Last update18:06 PM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
Time to crack down on settlement funding – by Yousef Munayyer
Time to crack down on settlement funding – by Yousef Munayyer
To say that the proliferation of Israeli settlements in Occupied Palestinian Territory is an impediment to peace is an understatement.
Thursday, July 22,2010 14:13
by Yousef Munayyer sabbah.biz

To say that the proliferation of Israeli settlements in Occupied Palestinian Territory is an impediment to peace is an understatement. As Israel continues to gobble up Palestinian land, the individual rights of landowners and the Palestinian people are trampled upon, leaving no realistic peace process of which to speak.

Ever since the Israeli occupation began in 1967, the United States has held that the transfer of Israel's civilian population into those territories is illegal and contrary to the Fourth Geneva Convention, an agreement that both Israel and the United States are party to. Consecutive presidential administrations have taken public stances against settlement building.

President Obama's recent national security strategy identifies securing a peace agreement as a key national security interest. Last year, in Cairo, President Obama restated the importance of a peace agreement and said that the United States does not recognize the legitimacy of continued Israeli settlements.

This makes the premise of a recent New York Times story exposing the extent of funds from American tax payers to support the continuation of Israeli settlements so disturbing. The story highlighted an issue that has long been problematic for activists and policy-makers alike. Hundreds of millions of U.S. tax dollars in deductible contributions are funneled into occupied territory through American charities to fund the enterprise that is killing the very peace process the United States aims to champion.

The extent of the networks operating here in the United States to support Israel's settlements is vast and likely much greater than what the Times story revealed. Certainly, charities in the business of subsidizing colonization have made efforts to disguise their contributions, and these efforts will continue as more light is shed on these controversial transactions.

The time has come for a comprehensive effort to crack down on this obvious loophole in U.S. foreign policy. Stating opposition to settlements, while allowing pro-settlement groups in this country to funnel tax dollars to Israel's hilltop colonies, undergirds the perception of hypocrisy Middle Easterners are all too accustomed to associating with the United States.

Thus far, actions to counter the efforts of pro-settlement funders using a tax-deductible status have been limited to filing complaints with the Internal Revenue Service (IRS). Through this method, activists have been able to register a complaint with the IRS, usually claiming a settlement-funding charity either engages in misleading fundraising or funds discriminatory practices.

Yet even though these efforts are noble attempts by activists to halt funding to settlements, they have yielded few results and rely on the IRS to follow through on complaints with little precedent or the tangible evidence necessary to open investigations.

A new approach is necessary to ensure that U.S. tax dollars are in line with U.S. foreign policy. Instead of a citizen-initiated, grassroots effort to mobilize the IRS, a government-led interagency approach to comprehensively crack down on the funding of illegal Israeli settlements in occupied territory is needed.

Luckily, such an approach would not require significant changes in policy, the rearranging of agencies or even significant expansion of any particular agency. The mechanisms for enforcement are already in place.

FinCEN, or the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network, became an official branch of the Treasury Department with the passage of the USA PATRIOT act in 2002. It is tasked with enforcing laws and regulations relating to financial crimes like money laundering and foreign terrorism finance. The foreign component of this policy, of course, involves the State Department. When it comes to combating international terrorism finance, for example, the agencies work together to prevent funding to organizations designated by the State Department as Foreign Terrorist Organizations.

In fact, in 1995, then President Clinton issued Executive Order 12947 which stated that acts that "disrupt the Middle East peace process constitute an unusual and extraordinary threat to the national security, foreign policy, and economy of the United States" and funding of these acts is illegal and prohibited. In this context, the Executive Order was targeting militant organizations, Arab and Jewish alike, who used violence against civilians.

Minor changes in legislation or an Executive Order could allow the State Department to maintain a similar list of settlement organizations which American banks and charities would not legally be allowed to deal with, and would give FinCEN the appropriate authority to crack down on organizations in the United States which direct U.S. tax dollars to settlements.

These settlements continue to prolong the Arab-Israeli conflict which General Petraeus recently cited as a significant complicating factor for U.S. objectives throughout the region.

Few problems facing the United States are so obvious. Even fewer have such obvious solutions. The rest is just a matter of political will. So long as American interests are the first priority, lawmakers should have an easy time correcting such a glaring and dangerous problem.

* Yousef Munayyer is the Executive Director of the Jerusalem Fund and the Palestine Center.


tags: Israeli Settlements / Israeli Settlers / Palestinian Land / 1967 / Palestinian People / Obama / Middle East / Arabs / Jews / Arab-Israeli Conflict / / Occupied Palestinian / Obama Administration
Posted in Palestine  
Related Articles
Israeli settlers attempt to burn historical mosque in Jaffa
British Jews support Israeli war crimes
Why Are Liberals So Angry With President Obama?
43 years on: the 1967 war-revisited
Arabs are more nuanced in judging America's behavior
A day in November: will Barack Obama face up to Israel lobby blackmail?
Default Positions: U.S. immigration & Israeli settlements
The Holocaust isn’t just about Jews
Israeli settlers set fire to historical Petra hotel in O. Jerusalem
The Structural Hopelessness of US Policy Toward the Middle East
Can Obama erase ‘Bush nostalgia’ in the Middle East?
Israeli Arabs urged to try 'reverse discrimination' against Jews
Israeli settlers pour boiling water on Palestinian workman in W. Bank
IOA confiscates Palestinian land in Jenin, detains West Bankers
IOA plans more expropriation of Palestinian land in OJ
Mousa: Storming Aqsa an insult to Arabs
Obama Administration Unsupportive of Middle East Democracy?
Bahar: The Palestinian people in Gaza made heroic epics during the Israeli war
Is the Qur’an hostile to Jews and Christians?
Hamas: European statement does not meet Palestinian people's aspirations
Ahmad: The Palestinian people reject partition today as they did 62 years ago
WCC calls to freeze and dismantle Israeli settlements
The 1967-war revisited
Expert: Obama’s Administration Prioritises settlement of Arab-Israeli Conflict
Galloway: Oslo did not liberate one inch of the Palestinian lands
The Power and Necessity of Humor in the Arab-Israeli Conflict
MPAC Commends President’s Call for End of Israeli Occupation of Palestinian Land