Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Tue109 2018

Last update19:14 PM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
:: Issues > Iran
What if the Next Iranian Regime is Just as Bad as This One?
What if the Next Iranian Regime is Just as Bad as This One?
There is another issue that sanctions advocates never address: what if their proposal results in a new government, but the new government wants to pursue a bomb and continue Iran’s foreign policy? As far as they are concerned, nothing meaningful will have changed...
Tuesday, March 2,2010 09:11
by Shadi Hamid Democracy Arsenal

There is another issue that sanctions advocates never address: what if their proposal results in a new government, but the new government wants to pursue a bomb and continue Iran’s foreign policy? As far as they are concerned, nothing meaningful will have changed...

The fantasies of Richard Haass aside, there is no guarantee that a new civilian leadership will make the Iranian government more “moderate” abroad (i.e., accommodating to U.S. demands). First, the new leadership may not want to end its support for Hizbullah and Hamas, and it may not want to abandon pursuit of nuclear weapons

Even if this assessment were accurate, having a democratic Iran whose foreign policy was just as bad would be an improvement over the status quo, not to mention the moral imperative involved. But there's a more fundamental misunderstanding involved here. Almost definitionally, a democratic Iran, by virtue of its democratic nature, would likely have a less destabilizing foreign policy, even allowing for the likelihood it would still pursue the bomb and perhaps support Hamas and Hezbollah.

After all, our problem with Iran is not just that it's pursuing a nuclear program but that it's pursuing a nuclear program combined with the fact that it's a theocracy and/or military dictatorship. We can say there is an interesting interaction effect between these two variables. The authoritarian nature is likely amplified by the active pursuit of nuclear weapons, while the potentially destructive effects of Iran having nuclear weapons is amplified by the authoritarian nature of its regime. 

One can envision a democratically-elected Iranian government that pursues nuclear weapons, offers rhetorical support to Hamas and Hezbollah, but also enjoys better relations with the U.S. and the international community, because democracies, all other things being equal, can be expected to be less reckless and inconsistent. In democracies, foreign policy decision-making is distributed among a larger number of people, with more veto points, and is to some degree subject to popular consent, rather than being overly dependent on one individual or a small clique of individuals as is often the case in autocratic regimes. 

--

The Source

tags: Iran / Ahmadinejad / Hamas / Iranian Regime / Iranian Government / Hizbullah / Nuclear Weapons / Democratic Nature / Islamic Revolution
Posted in Iran , Democracy  
Print
islam is the solution lida
"...but that it's pursuing a nuclear program combined with the fact that it's a theocracy and/or military dictatorship." !!!! It's strange to find sth like this on Ikhwanweb. I guess only Muslims care about what are the problems of ikhwan in Egypt. Ikhwans can not count on so called moderates (pro-west) in Iran because already you're under pressure of a moderate gov (pro- west) there in Egypt which to Muslim population of middle east is not Al-Aadil (moderate and just). Let us define Adl based on our Islamic teachings and not in terms of EU which uses NATO (kind of demo-n-cracy) to bring its wishes to life in Islamic countries !!!!
Saturday, December 18,2010 12:14
Related Articles
MB MP's condemn execution of Iranian opposition.
Nothing More Dangerous Than a Recovering "Realist?"
An American World of War
Talking to Turkey
Obama Aggresses Media echoes lie Iran threatens to
Iran's Islamic regime is no model to follow
Syria’s MB Controller to talk about his angry message on Islamic movements close to power
Robert Bernstein: Human Shield for Criticism of Israel
Media Critique on the Marwa El-Sherbini Case Desperately Seeking Intercultural Sensitivity
The war for Muslim minds: an interview with Gilles Kepel
Obama-Mania: An Opportunity but Also a Bottom Line
Tehran troubles
Radical Islam in decline
Will Iran Instigate a Foreign Crisis from a Domestic Crisis?
’The bottom line’
Iran and Washington’s Hidden Hand
Iran’s Second Islamic Revolution?
Does The West Really Understand What Goes On In Iran?
The Fall and Rise of the Islamic State
Revolutionary Guards’ soft power: from “cyber repression” to “humanitarian action”