Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Thu93 2020

Last update18:06 PM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
:: Issues > Human Rights
Arab Society and Men with Guns
Arab Society and Men with Guns
Why it is that every time civil society and NGO activists launch a new initiative or organization, they must first get permission to do so from the men with guns who hold power in our region? Asks Rami G. Khouri.
Tuesday, February 2,2010 11:52
by Rami G. Khouri. Middle East Online


AMMAN - Every time I go to a conference or workshop on civil society and non-governmental organizations in the Arab world, I come away with the same mixed feelings of despondency and pride. I am despondent because decades of work and tens of millions of dollars of local and foreign money that have been spent on strengthening civil society have had very limited impact on the quality of life of ordinary citizens in our region. Civil society institutions continue to be almost totally at the mercy of state power and controls.

Yet I am proud because tens of thousands of Arab men and women nevertheless continue to strive for better societies where citizens can form associations and organizations to work in that vast public space between the family and the state. The quest to develop a thriving civil society reflects the desire to create -- and is an indispensable part of -- a society governed by the rule of law, defined by social equity, and propelled on a trajectory of growth, pluralism, and prosperity by developing and unleashing the full talents of all their citizens.

This was brought home to me once again this week when I attended a two-day conference in Jordan organized by the Foundation for the Future, one of the groups spawned by the G-8 process that has attempted to prod democratic governance, human rights and reform in the Middle East through supporting initiatives by civil society. Efforts to attain that aim remain more impressive than the achievements. Some outstanding presentations based on solid research and serious analysis emphasized several points that we have know for decades: civil society institutions are a critical component of a stable and credible democracy, many wise and brave men and women in our region work hard and against great odds to promote such institutions, yet Arab civil society remains structurally stunted, for various reasons.

The slow pace of progress for civil society -- as opposed, say, to the development of the private sector, ATM bank machines, shopping malls, smuggling networks, Colonel Sanders fried chicken franchises, or information and communication technology -- is due primarily to the resistance of the prevailing power structure to real change that leads to sharing power with others beyond the contours of ruling elites and their guards and business associates. We know this and have known it since soon after the birth of the modern Arab state system was overtaken by the advent of the security state, where power is closely monopolized in the hands of a few men who control, pay, and are supported by many other men with guns.

Civil society institutions -- NGOs, along with professional and business associations, religious and tribal groups, and advocacy organizations with a narrow focus -- essentially fall into one of two kinds of bodies: They are utilitarian and service delivery organizations that respond to a specific need (e.g., pre-schools, care for the handicapped, professional standards for barbers and hairdressers, or environmental protection), or, they operate in the more contested realm of national values, policy-making and asset allocation (e.g., promoting human rights and democracy, enhancing political parties and parliamentary performance, the status of women, the rule of law and accountability, or civilian oversight of the security sector).

Civil society groups in the first category tend to do well, and in some cases are even consulted by the state, because they do not threaten the state’s monopoly on power, and even relieve the state of some service delivery obligations (care for handicapped, helping the poor, protecting wildlife, etc.). Organizations in the second category, however, have minimal, if any, impact because of their core actions: They tend to question and defy the norms and policies of the state, they demand to hold the state accountable for its actions, and they seek to play a role in setting national policies and allocating resources.

The fundamental dynamic at play in the interaction between civil society and the state in the Arab world is the tension between knowledge, norms and power. Civil society and NGOs succeed in very narrow confines when they play a utilitarian role that complements but does not intrude into the authority of the state. They have virtually zero impact or credibility when they try to modify the exercise of state or elite power. It remains the case that those who seek to make a difference in the Arab world have to peacefully but forcefully contest the monopoly of power by the state -- the sort of nonviolent challenge that Solidarity mounted against the Soviet-supported Polish state in the 1980s, which ultimately led to the collapse of the Soviet system. No wonder, therefore, that every time civil society and NGO activists launch a new initiative or organization, they must first get permission to do so from the men with guns who hold power in our region.

Rami G. Khouri is Editor-at-large of The Daily Star, and Director of the Issam Fares Institute for Public Policy and International Affairs at the American University of Beirut, in Beirut, Lebanon.

Copyright © 2010 Rami G. Khouri – distributed by Agence Global


tags: Civil Society / NGOs / Rights Groups / Workshop / Arab Regimes / Civil Society Organizations / Human Rights Activists
Posted in Human Rights  
Related Articles
In a workshop on the internet and its role in the movement for democracy
The charges against the Egyptian government for violations of Human Rights
150 Activists Strike in Front of the Cairo World Trade Center
Workshop: Gaza soil contaminated with radioactive materials and unfit for use
When the United Nations is being used as a means to limit the work of NGOs
Egypt: Rights groups warn of “political considerations” over human rights
Workshop in Cairo discusses Al-qaeda's future.
The Egyptian government paves the way for Further restrictions imposed on the Civil Society
Morsi: Zionist Lobby behind Attempts to Hinder Civil Society Work in Europe
Funding GONGOs against democracy
Civil Society in Egypt: A Catalyst for Democratization?
Egypt: regime targets activists, NGOs
Rights groups urge press, civil society to speak out against Brotherhood crackdowns
Report around Activities of the Civil Society Organizations’ Inspection Visit to Al Qanater Jail.
Closing NGOs underming Abu Mazen government
Egyptian NGOs call for change in third round of elections
NGOs’ Reports on the Polls
The birth of a global civil society
Mohammed El-Sayed Sae’ed: Egyptian Civil Society Under Fire*
Libyan MB Chairman: We seek Civil Society-Inspired Reform