Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Thu93 2020

Last update18:06 PM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
:: Issues > Eye on IOF
Reflections after J Street’s first Conference
Reflections after J Street’s first Conference
Do I see the Israel of today as embodying the best ideals of Judaism, as acting as a light unto the nations? No, I do not. But that does not mean that I should abandon my ideals, my goals and my dreams as to what the Jewish state should and indeed could be, says Moriel Rothman.
Friday, January 1,2010 16:38
by Moriel Rothman Middle East Online

 I am a Zionist and therefore I am pro-peace

MIDDLEBURY, Vermont - Having attended J Street’s first national conference in Washington, DC this October, I want to add my voice to the media controversy surrounding the new pro-Israel, pro-peace organisation. I am writing from the perspective of a student, a connected Jew, a liberal, an Israeli citizen, and an American citizen when I say “finally”. Finally, a pro-Israel organisation that does not deny or turn a blind eye to the immense suffering of the Palestinian people and the deep legitimacy of their narrative. Finally, a pro-peace organisation that does not demonise Israel and grossly oversimplify the situation with labels like “colonialism” and “apartheid”. Finally, an organisation that proudly declares its support for Israel as a Jewish state, and that proudly emphasises the need for the creation of a viable Palestinian state. Finally.


J Street, through its programming, platforms and sheer energy, has shown its ability to provide an organisational voice to people like myself, people who love and are deeply connected to Israel, and who are immensely frustrated with and critical of many Israeli policies. Moreover, J Street represents a chance for people like myself to reclaim Zionism. The word Zionism has taken on such a pejorative connotation in the liberal world that many have been hesitant to use it to self-describe. This hesitance has been compounded by the fact that many of those loudly proclaiming to be “Zionist” are from the expansionist, extremist settler movement, which cares nothing about the plight or rights of the Palestinian people. I vehemently disagree with the latter group, but I am a Zionist. I believe in Israel, and I believe in Israel as a Jewish state. I believe in a Jewish state based on the best ideals Judaism has to offer: ideals of justice and repairing the world, ideals of tolerance and equality, ideals of hope. I believe in a Jewish state that acts as a “light unto the nations”.


Do I see the Israel of today as embodying the best ideals of Judaism, as acting as a light unto the nations? No, I do not. But that does not mean that I should abandon my ideals, my goals and my dreams as to what the Jewish state should and indeed could be. After all, the fact that the American system has left so many disenfranchised and suffering does not mean that we should give up on America and American democracy; it just means that we should work to change and better America, bringing it closer to its foundational ideals.


Returning to the subject of what Zionism means, the spirit of the J Street conference re-emphasised something that I have always believed: Zionism, while clearly a Jewish movement, has profoundly universal implications. Zionism was a movement formed from communal longing, from religious and cultural dedication, from historical roots and from the desire for Jewish people to be safe, secure and able to flourish. Thus, it is in fact through the very lens of Zionism that I am best able to understand the Palestinians’ desire for independence, for national self-determination and for freedom from the oppression and repression they have suffered throughout history. As such, it is through this reclaimed paradigm of Zionism that I aim to struggle for two viable and independent states, for the sake of the Jewish state and the Jewish people, and for the sake of Palestine and the Palestinians.


Finally, the J Street conference reaffirmed that the struggle to make Israel the type of Jewish state that I—and many others—long for cannot be accomplished through silence nor reactionary defensiveness. As a Jew, a liberal, a student, an American, an Israeli and a Zionist it is crucial that I actively support Israel when it does what I see as right, and speak out, loudly, strongly and with conviction when the Israeli state carries out unjust and immoral policies and actions. For indeed, such policies (the continuation of the occupation, for example) are, in a sense, anti-Zionist, both in their negative effects on the possibility of a democratic, Jewish state and in their inconsistency with core Jewish and Zionist values.


Moriel Rothman is a junior at Middlebury College, in Vermont. He was born in Jerusalem, studies political science and Arabic, and is co-President of Middlebury’s Hillel. This article is distributed by the Common Ground News Service (CGNews).



tags: Colonialism / Judaism / Israel / Liberalism / Pro-Peace / Palestinian Issue / Pro-Israeli Lobby / J Street / American Democracy
Posted in Eye on IOF , Other Views  
Related Articles
Breaking Palestine's Peaceful Protest
A Year Later: Gaza and Israel Both Under Siege
Is the Qur’an hostile to Jews and Christians?
J Street Conference Only Step One
Israeli rabbi describes Islam as “ugly”
Gideon Levy / Let's face the facts, Israel is a semi-theocracy
Israel is Unlikely to Yield
The Truth About Christian Zionists
Can the United States put pressure on Israel?: A user’s guide
McCain Rejects Hagee: How Long Before Major American Jewish Groups Do the Same?
Israel’s 60th Anniversary: Why are some people partying like it’s 1948?
Israeli Lobby - Article Collection
The US and the Palestinian-Israeli conflict, Al-Jazeerah
Cheney Unleashes the Dogs of War
Robert Satloff: Promoting a Balanced Understanding of the Middle East