Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Tue109 2018

Last update19:14 PM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
:: Issues > Islamic Movements
A Better Chance for Islamic Parties
A Better Chance for Islamic Parties
To succeed long-term Islamic parties need to learn how to lose, and regroup, as well as how to win, notes Terry Lacey.
In Egypt 88 members of parliament have won seats on an MB platform, on an urban groundswell for reform and new leadership. They seem to have more in common with the Turkish AKP, or the Indonesian Prosperous Justice Party (the PKS). This Islamic Egyptian parliamentary opposition could conceivably win an election in Cairo. In today´s Egypt this is revolutionary. Western silence on Egyptian democracy is such that if you listen hard you can hear the rice growing in the Nile delta.
Saturday, July 4,2009 10:30
by Terry Lacey Middle East Online

Hezbollah and its Christian allies lost the election in Lebanon. President Ahmadinejad won his election, but the Islamic Republic lost credibility. Support for Hamas is falling in some polls. The Parti Islam Se-Malaysia (PAS) has rejected a deal to join the ruling United Malays National Organization (UMNO) in power. Egypt is clamping down on the Muslim Brotherhood (MB). The Indonesian Islamic parties got their lowest vote for ten years in the April 9th general elections.

Despite these reports key Islamic parties are getting stronger, and moving more center-stage. The Justice and Development Party (AKP) is in power in Turkey while wider coalitions including Islamic parties are lining up in Indonesia, Malaysia and Palestine, or pre-party structures are gathering parliamentary strength, as in Egypt.

From the Islamic Salvation Front in Algeria in 1990, to the 2006 elections in Palestine, to the recent Egyptian general elections, and the Iranian Presidential elections, the West becomes nervous when Islamic parties do well, understating their strength.

In Lebanon, Hezbollah seem to have accepted political defeat gracefully, although they apparently won a clear majority of popular votes, by a ten percent margin, but not of seats, as reported by Franklin Lamb in the PalestineChronicle.com. Wisely they did not take to the streets on this. To succeed long-term Islamic parties need to learn how to lose, and regroup, as well as how to win.

With no militia, no threat of a state within a state and less baggage as a surrogate for radical states, Hezbollah, (with its allies) could lose support through lost sponsorship or stand stronger on its own feet, winning votes for wider coalitions stressing economic and social progress. But Hezbollah cannot modernize politically until the Palestine-Israel dispute no longer provides the rationale for the status quo.

President Ahmadinejad won the presidential elections with a reported 2:1 margin, despite irregularities, in line with a US-financed pre-poll telephone survey. Iranian leaders miscalculated, turning a widespread election protest within the political system into the start of a popular movement against it, fanned by Western, Arab and Muslim critics, with political conservatives fearing its radicalism and liberals favoring change.

If Iran is to strengthen democracy and not rely on repression, then the two polarized Muslim political camps have to unclench their fists with each other. Then Iran and the US can do the same. President Obama seems still open to this, despite the previous Bush-backed $400 million destabilization program, and its links to violent opposition.

Mainstream political Islam has little in common with the Iranian Islamic revolution and is not about violence or terrorism, but about economic, social and political reform, driven by Islamic identity and motivation. Mainstream Islamic parties do not necessarily want an Islamic state. Most do not. They vary in how Islamic they are, and how much they represent broader nationalist or reformist platforms.

Islamic parties are making progress in Indonesia, Malaysia and Turkey as well as Palestine and Egypt.

Hamas is gaining recognition and poised to become part of the peace via a national Palestinian coalition. Helena Cobban of the Christian Science Monitor after interviewing Khaled Meshal in Damascus compares the political evolution of Hamas with that of the African National Congress and Sinn Fein. She is right. It has more in common with them than with most Islamic parties. (Jakarta Globe 27.06.09).

In Egypt 88 members of parliament have won seats on an MB platform, on an urban groundswell for reform and new leadership. They seem to have more in common with the Turkish AKP, or the Indonesian Prosperous Justice Party (the PKS).

This Islamic Egyptian parliamentary opposition could conceivably win an election in Cairo. In today´s Egypt this is revolutionary. Western silence on Egyptian democracy is such that if you listen hard you can hear the rice growing in the Nile delta.

Meanwhile the PAS in Malaysia is seeking to reform a Muslim-majority nation in a rainbow coalition with non-Muslim political parties and supporters.

Arief Munandar writes in The Jakarta Post (30.06.09) that despite predictions of sunset for Indonesian Islamic parties, whose combined vote fell to 26 percent in the April general elections, they are now part of a winning coalition for the direct presidential elections on July 8th, which has a combined 67 percent support in the polls, led by incumbent President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono and his Democratic Party.

Indonesian Islamic parties have everything to play for up to 2014, when there will be a generational change in national political leadership, with “enough room not just to survive but even to grow”, as Munandar concludes. He suggests they should focus on social problems, unemployment and health care.

He advises them “to base their bargaining position on high standards of political ethics and behavior, rather than resorting to threats or arrogance in the media”.

All of these movements can learn from the AKP in Turkey, where you can support an Islamic Party in power, swim on the beach with your family or friends and go to a disco afterwards. As we do in Indonesia.

Maybe, despite a negative press, political Islam is learning to swim with the tide.

Terry Lacey is a development economist who writes from Jakarta on modernization in the Muslim world, investment and trade relations with the EU and Islamic banking.

The Source


Posted in Islamic Movements , Political Islam Studies  
Add Comment Send to Friend Print
Related Articles
Mauritanian Islamists “A Comprehensive Enhancement Project for the Presidency”
Islamist policy shift?
The essence of Islamist resistance
Islamist radicalisation: the challenge for euro-mediterranean relations
Obama hints acceptance of elected Islamists
Will Islamists Be Part Of The President’s New Dialogue?
Islamists Lose Ground in the Middle East
Miliband Calls for Fair Engagement with Islamists
Kuwaiti Elections: Advancement for Women, Retreat for Islamists
Muslim Brotherhood Falters as Egypt Outflanks Islamists
Europe’s engagement with moderate Islamists
Indonesia’s election a triumph of pragmatism over ideology, moderate Muslims over radical Islamists
Call to make Islamist groups part of solution in building institutions
Islamist Parties and Democracy
Islamist Govts Not the Enemy, Say Mideast Experts
El-Katatny In Beirut Discusses Post-Islamist Political Participation
Sultani to Ikhwanweb: Ending Islamists-Regime Clash Through Expanding Margin of Agreement, Dialogue
Egypt Bans Islamist Reporter From Medical Travel
Democracy and the Muslim world: the “post-Islamist” turn
U.S.: Islamist Govts Not the Enemy, Say Mideast Experts
Islamist-Leftist Cooperation in the Arab World
Violent Islamists vs. Non-Violent Islamists
When Islamists Wield Power
Islamist setbacks prompt strategic rethink
MB Bloc, World Islamist MPs Denounce Duweik’s Prison Sentence
Islamists in Politics: The Dynamics of Participation
Democracy ‘normalizes’ Islamists?
Islamists at the Gate, But It’s Okay
The Islamist Dilemma
Resolving America’s Islamist Dilemma:Lessons from South and Southeast Asia
Why Does Islamists’ Dialog With The West Stumble?
Islamist Parties and Democracy: Going Back to the Origins
What Moderate Islamists Expect from Obama?
Islamists’ Rise Could Benefit Women’s Rights
Contemporary Islamists in the Middle East
Arab democracy needs ‘Islamist revision’
’Islamists edge towards democracy’
Islamist Parties and Democracy: Three Kinds of Movements
Reuters: Egypt’s Islamists Sees Election Setback in 2010
Mauritania Islamists: Military Coup Threatens the Country’s Stability
Party Leader Says Islamist Trend is Fact in Mauritania, Other Countries
Islamists gain from Mideast turmoil and democratic deficit
Arab Islamists, their internal democracy
Reform between Islamists, Secularists
Turkish Islamist Intellectuals at Left-Leaning Crossroads
The West and the Islamists
POMED Notes: Islamist Parties and Democracy
The Islamist Conundrum
EVENT on "Islamist Parties and Democracy"
Experts Urge U.S. to Talk with Islamist Movements to Encourage Democratic Trends
Experts Urge U.S. to Talk with Islamist Movements to Encourage Democratic Trends
US/INTERNATIONAL: Dialogue with Islamists
Islamists win seats in Kuwait Parliamentary poll
Why Islamists Don’t Win Elections
Political Islam and Democracy - What do Islamists and Islamic Movements want?
EGYPT: Islamists Given Jail, and a Message
Jordanian Islamist warns of an unprecedented reaction if Gaza siege persisted
Ikhwanweb Featured in BBC Report: Egypt Islamists Wait for Power
Islamist Group Pressures Egypt’s Ruling Party
In Egypt, Islamist runs against the odds
Morocco Islamists Harassed by Security Services
Campaigning for all (including Islamists)
Egypt bars 90 percent of Islamist hopefuls from vote
Egypt Islamists in Hiding Ahead of Vote
700 potential opposition candidates arrested ahead of Egypt’s elections: Islamist lawmaker
Egypt Islamists fight obstacles to enter council vote
A Moderate Islamist is Arrested in Egypt - and What it Means for Us
Moroccan Authorities Detain 5 Leaders of 2 Islamic Parties
What it means... Yemeni Islamists’ stance on democracy
Islamist target Hirsi Ali seeks French protection
Political Islam and Democracy - What do Islamists and Islamic Movements want?
Refusing talk to facilitate talk – the paradox of Islamist dialogue: An overdue task or an exercise
Islamist Movements and the Political Challenge: An Alternate Perspective
Let’s not forget the moderate Islamists
The Islamist opposition online in Egypt and Jordan
The Islamist opposition online in Egypt and Jordan
Analysis: Not all Islamists are equal
Workshop on Islamists Future in Arab Parliaments
Islamists emerge in stifled Tunisia
Islamist Pragmatists Ripe for Engagement?
Egyptian court drops terrorism charges against Islamists
Elections in Jordan: Poor Showing for Islamists
Moderate Islamists and peaceful democracy
EGYPT: Islamist Draft Manifesto Stirs Controversy
In Focus: The Autumn of Arab Islamists
Islamist threat is exaggerated
Jordan Vote Reflects Islamic Parties’ Slide
Why are Western officials hesitant to talk to moderate Islamists ?
The Political Implications of the Hamas Electoral Victory from the Islamist Perspective
Jordan’s Islamists Seek Offices Their Allies Scorn
What today’s Islamists Want
Looking for Moderate Islamists
Debunking the myth of Islamist intransigence
Islamist questioning and Colonialism: towards an understanding of the Islamist oeuvre
Turkish Paradox: Progressive Islamists versus Reactionary Secularists
Egypt: Security, Political, and Islamist Challenges
The Islamist spring, is it over?
Secular Tunisia may face a new, younger Islamist challenge
From Jordan to Morocco; Are the Arab Islamist Movements in Decline?
Early Islamist responses to Western challenge
POMED-SAIS Event on Islamist Political Participation in Turkey and Morocco
EVENT: Islamist Political Participation and Democratic Development
Perceptions of identity: Islamist identity and neoconservatism
Do not undermine moderate Islamists: The case of Muslim Brotherhood leader, Khayrat El-Shater
Success of Turkey’s AK Party must not dilute worries over Arab Islamists
Moroccan Elections: A new rise for Islamists?
A Response to Western Views of Islamist Movements
Amnesty says Jailed Egypt Islamist leader in poor health
Turkey, Palestine, Morocco: No Welcome to Islamists
Islamist democracy
A shift in the thinking of Egyptian Islamists
Islamists under fire draft first political programme
Are Islamists Heading to Power?
Islamists accuse Egypt police of kidnap, torture
Can Morocco’s Islamists check al-Qaida?
Egypt Islamist trial resumes behind closed doors
Muslim Brotherhood, Contemporary Islamic Parties
Deconstructing Islamist Participation
Amnesty wants observers at Egypt Islamists’ trial
Islamist Movements in the Arab World and the 2006 Lebanon War
Top Islamist: Don’t Prejudge Siniora’s Gov’t
U.S. Tactics Fuel for Islamists
Alongside Its Islamist Ideology, Hamas Presents Pragmatic Positions
Despotic Sentences against Six Islamists
Fotoh: West Must Not Pressure Regimes To Curb Islamists
Engagement or Quarantine: How to Deal with the Islamist Advance
Islamist Political Parties in Kuwait and Morocco
Persecuted Islamists Pledge Peace
Islamists between Regime and Electorate’
The Convenient Islamist Threat
The Rise of Islamists in the Middle East
View from Dubai: Why the West must engage Islamists
Anti-globalists reach out to Islamists
Islamist diversity is al-Qaeda’s enemy
How North African Nations Are Dealing With Islamist Resurgence
’Brotherhood’ Blogs In Egypt Offer View Of Young Islamists
Islamists Achieve Landslide Victories In Elections of Jordanian Doctors’ Syndicate
Turkey tests Islamist appetite for democracy
Islamist MPs In the Dock
The Military, the Cops, and the Islamists
Jordan Islamists met with US democracy experts
Georgetown Symposium on Islamist Politics
Jordan’s Islamists& Nationalists Garner Most Dental Syndicate Seats
Islamists: To Deal, or Not To Deal?
The Islamists’ Party in Egypt…No Hope
Morocco’s Islamists Are Slowly Winning
Turkey: Islamists pay a price for victory
The United States talks to Islamists. So what?
Should the West dialogue with Islamists?
More Expert Voices on Political Islamists and the Dangers of Current Policy
Controversy Among Reformists in the Arab World Over Dialogue With Islamist Groups
Movie Clears Islamists of Persecuting Copts
Katatny: Dialogue Between Islamists And The West a Necessity
Dialogue manifisto Between Islamists And The West
What Islamists Need to Be Clear About: The Case of the Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood
Islamists and the Ballot Box
Islamists urge Egyptians to vote out Mubarak
Egyptian Islamists hit streets
Jordan’s MB Warns Against Curbing Freedoms, Pressures on Islamists
Jordan: Islamists Win Bar Association Elections