Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Tue109 2018

Last update19:14 PM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
MB Around The World
The next Supreme Guide of the Muslim Brotherhood
The next Supreme Guide of the Muslim Brotherhood
Mohammed Mehdi Akef, the Supreme Guide of the Muslim Brotherhood, has just announced that he will not seek a second term and will step down within a few months. This announcement by the 81 year old Akef creates an extremely interesting and important moment in the history of the Brotherhood. The change in leadership has potentially wide-ranging implications for moderate Islamist movements throughout the Middle East
Thursday, March 26,2009 08:54
by Marc Lynch Foreign Policy

Mohammed Mehdi Akef, the Supreme Guide of the Muslim Brotherhood, has just announced that he will not seek a second term and will step down within a few months.  This announcement by the 81 year old Akef creates an extremely interesting and important moment in the history of the Brotherhood.  The change in leadership has potentially wide-ranging implications for moderate Islamist movements throughout the Middle East.  Will he be replaced by a politically-oriented reformist or by a religiously-oriented conservative?  Will he be replaced by an Egyptian or by a non-Egyptian from the global Brotherhood movement?  And will his successor retain Akef"s strong hostility to al-Qaeda style jihadism and commitment to participation in the political process?

 It may surprise people to realize that Akef will be replaced in an internally democratic process.   As I understand the process, the Supreme Guide is elected by the Brotherhood"s Shura Council, which has 100 members -- 80 of them elected by the membership of the organization and 20 of them holding ex officio membership (i.e. current and former members of the Guidance Council). Since the Muslim Brotherhood remains by far the largest and most politically significant mainstream Sunni Islamist movement, this internal election may be one of the most significant in the Middle East"s so-called "year of elections."

 Mehdi Akef, who took over as Supreme Guide in 2004, has always been something of a cipher. His public speeches tend toward the uncompromising, with a hard line on Israel, the United States, and most public issues.  He has repeatedly inflamed controversies with his fiery rhetoric, offering plenty of fodder for Brotherhood-bashers seeking to demonstrate the organization"s true radicalism.  Indeed, one of my suggestions to the Muslim Brotherhood in a Foreign Policy magazine article a few years ago for improving relations with the U.S. was that Akef personally should keep his mouth shut. 

 At the same time, he has presided over a Supreme Guide"s office dominated by pragmatic, politically-oriented reformers who have charted a difficult but quite impressive path through Egypt"s political turbulence.  Under Akef the Muslim Brotherhood participated fully in the 2005 Parliamentary elections, and then remained committed to the democratic process despite intense regime repression and repeated provocations (including wide-scale arrests of its members and the wholesale banning of its candidates from municipal and upper-house elections). Under Akef, we"ve seen the emergence of a new generation of young, reformist Brotherhood members and bloggers. And under his guidance the Brotherhood has consistently and rapidly condemned al-Qaeda terrorist attacks everywhere (though, consistent with the widespread Arab and Muslim distinction between terrorism and "resistance to occupation", his MB refused to condemn Hamas violence and was conflicted on the violence in Iraq).  

 Over the last few years, the Brotherhood has come under really intense pressure from the Mubarak regime -- which most interpret as punishment for its too-successful participation in democratic elections.  A number of its senior leaders have been arrested and tried in state security courts, including the still-imprisoned moderate icon Khairat al-Shater.  Muslim Brotherhood watchers have been trying to judge the internal trends within the organization under these pressures:  has the repression weakened the hands of the pragmatists, whose advocacy of democratic participation has offered few rewards?  Is there a rising "salafi" trend within the movement, which prefers to back away from politics and focus on dawa, religion and social services?

 This makes the selection of the new Supreme Guide extremely significant.  The choice of a reformist leader, such as Abd el-Monem Abou el-Fattouh or Essam el-Erian, would be a powerful signal of the commitment to the democratic game and moderate doctrine.  The selection of a conservative, dawa-oriented leader would signal frustration with politics and a more inward-looking organization -- and could potentially drive the reformist trends within the movement to split off in frustration.  Mohammad Habib, the current Deputy Supreme Guide, would most likely signify continuity with Akef"s tenure, balancing the two wings. A choice from outside Egypt, as advocated by European MB leader Kamal Helbawi, might signal a move away from the internal focus on Egyptian politics and a revitalization of the fairly weak and loosely-connected global organization.  

 The leading Muslim Brotherhood reformist blogger Abd al-Monem Mahmoud wrote a thoughtful post the other day asking about the future of the reformist trend in the Brotherhood.  The election of a new Supreme Guide may be one of the most important signals as to the answer to this vital question.

The Source


Posted in MB Around The World , MB Understanding , Activites  
Add Comment Send to Friend Print
Related Articles
Akef Strongly Condemns Egypt’s Bomb Blast
Akef: The Egyptian-French initiative is an Israeli request
Akef Urges Arab, Muslim Rulers Take Joint Attitude Against Countries Blocking Gaza Ceasefire
Interview with Muslim Brotherhood Chairman Mohamed Mahdy Akef
Akef calls on Egyptian people to participate in relief convoys to Gaza
Akef Congratulates Muslims On Ramadan
Akef Praises European Activists For Breaking Gaza Siege
Mahdy Akef: Freedom Requires Sacrifice
Akef Calls on Palestinian Factions to Stop Mutual Accusations, Detentions
Akef Calls for Reconciliation among Lebanese Currents
Mahdi Akef: Muslim Brotherhood Rejects Gamal Mubarak as President
Akef: Arresting “Esraaâ€‌ proves the enmity among Egyptian regime and the whole society
Akef Criticizes Arrest of Female Political Activist Israa Abdel Fattah
Akef: Applying Sharia Reinforces Status of Minorities in Muslim State
Akef in Conference for Supporting Palestine : Camp David Treaty Isolated Egypt
Akef: Arresting Supporters of Palestinian People a ’Shame for Egyptian Regime’
Akef urges new PA government to fulfill aspirations of Palestinian people
Akef Offers Iranian President His Condolences Over Earthquake
Akef: Palestinian people and factions unity sacred issue
Akef congratulates Pope Shenouda for the Coptic Easter Holiday
Mr. Akef Weekly Address: Unity Among Muslims is Necessity
Akef Denies Muslim Brotherhood is Eyeing The Presidency
Akef Offers His Condolences To Victims of Indonesian Earthquake
Akef Warns of Arab Regimes’ Conspiracy Against PA
Akef Expresses His Condolences For The Death of Archbishop Matta el Meskeen
Akef Appeals For Solidarity With Palestinian & Lebanese People
Akef Denies MB Undergoing Military Training
Akef mourns Sheikh Abdullah Al-Mitawa
Akef: Freedom Is A Major Islamic Principle
Mr. Akef Barred From Traveling To Saudi Arabia To Perform Umra.
MB’s Akef Phones Palestinian Leaders to Solve Current Crisis
Constitution changes would bring dark future: Akef
Worried About The Future, Mr. Akef’s Interview With Al-Ahram Weekly
Akef Offers His Deep Condolence to the Egyptian People
Excerpts of Mr. Akef Speech on Human Right
Akef: Muslims Are Able to Deter the New Colonization Project
Speech of Mr. Mohamed Mahdi Akef, Ramadan Iftar Party
Akef: Reform in Egypt is inevitable and the eternal rule is unacceptable.
Akef Urges Muslim And Christian Nations to Help Palestinians
Akef: Despite Political Tyranny, People Will Win