Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Tue109 2018

Last update19:14 PM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
:: Issues > Human Rights
New Setback for Freedom of Opinion and Expression
New Setback for Freedom of Opinion and Expression
Hadayek Al-Qobba Misdemeanor Court Sentences Chairman of the board of Al-Ahrar Newspaper and Two Others to Three Months Imprisonment
Hadayek Al-Qobba Misdemeanor Court on 28 / 2 / 2009 (the misdemeanor of giving a false account) issued a verdict in case No. 27375 of 2008 brought by the Health Insurance General Organization against Salah Qabdaya, chairman of board of Al-Ahram newspaper, and Essam Kamil, managing editor, and Ala’ Shabal, a journalist at the newspaper, in absentia. They were sentenced to imprisonment for one month and a bail of 100 L.E. for each of them with a payment of 501 L.E. as temporary repara
Wednesday, March 11,2009 02:24
EOHR.org

Hadayek Al-Qobba Misdemeanor Court on 28 / 2 / 2009 (the misdemeanor of giving a false account) issued a verdict in case No. 27375 of 2008 brought  by the Health Insurance General Organization   against Salah Qabdaya, chairman of board of Al-Ahram newspaper, and Essam Kamil, managing editor, and Ala’ Shabal, a journalist at the newspaper, in absentia. They were sentenced to imprisonment for one month and a bail of 100 L.E. for each of them with a payment of 501 L.E. as temporary reparation.

The events of the case go back to 20th November 2008 whereby the newspaper published, in issue number 6171 of 20 /  11 / 2008, the news article with the headline ‘Report to the Attorney General against the Minister of Health and the Manager of Health Insurance in Al-Gharbiya’. The father of the four-year-old child Mahmud Hamada accused those responsible for health insurance in Al-Gharbiya of medical negligence and causing the mental handicapping and loss of senses of his only child. This is what caused the organization to submit an immediate misdemeanor case against those mentioned, accusing them of giving a false account. However, none of those mentioned attended the sessions.

In addition to this, the organization  presented a complaint to the chairman of the Press High Council about what was published in the newspaper to take steps towards falsifying the news issued in the newspaper and to question  newspaper in accordance with law 96 of 1996 in the matter of press management.

In this regard, the Egyptian Organization for Human Rights expresses its deep concern about the continuing application of the imprisonment policy for journalists as it contradicts the Egyptian constitution as well as international covenants  and agreements that confirm the principles of freedom of opinion and  expression and holding of ideas , in addition to the freedom to circulate information and the right to know and obtain information without impediments. At the head of these international agreements is Article 19 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights that confirms the “freedom of opinion and expression; this right includes freedom to hold opinions without interference and to seek, receive and impart information and ideas through any media and regardless of frontiers.” The Egyptian government ratified these treaties and therefore they became an essential part of domestic law according to article 151 of the Constitution.

Paragraph 2 of article 19 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights requires the protection of the right to freedom of expression, and it not only contains the freedom to “impart information and ideas” but also the freedom to “seek” and “receive” them “regardless of frontiers” and “through any media” whether that be through writing, printing, art or any other media that is chosen. Given the development of modern mass media, active measures must be taken to prevent this censorship of the media, which contradicts the right of every individual to freedom of expression in a way that is not provided in paragraph 3 of article 19.   

Paragraph 3 freely confirms that practicing the right to freedom of expression entails special duties and responsibilities. In this way, this right may be subjected to certain restrictions to safeguard the interests of other people or the interests of society as a whole.  However, when a state imposes restrictions on practicing the freedom of expression, these restrictions may not endanger the right itself. They may not be imposed but for one goal shown in paragraphs A and B in paragraph 3. They must be justified by being necessary for the state to ensure on of these goals. 


EOHR sees this sentence of imprisonment as confirmation of the state’s violation of the principle of freedom of opinion and expression, to circulate information and right to knowledge. EOHR also requests an end to these type of sentences that President Mubarak promised to put a stop to in February 2004 protecting freedom of the press and journalists and putting into practice the constitution and international pacts that ensure the right to freedom of opinion and expression. Fines should be sufficient, with the placement of a maximum limit, and the person affected by the publication should have the right to reply in the same newspaper and to have the civil claim to request appropriate compensation in front of a civil court if the journalist broke the law.


Posted in Human Rights  
Add Comment Send to Friend Print
Related Articles
Ahram Journalists Protest, Request Chair’s Leave
Moroccan anti-corruption journalist & blogger arrested Journalist should be questioned not detained
Egyptian Bloggers and Journalists in the Hot Seat
Academics and Journalist in Gaza call for boycotting the BBC
34 journalists killed in 2008
The following individuals have been killed in 2008 because of their work as journalists
Police in Sudan arrest dozens of journalists protesting against media censorship
Court Releases Journalist Hosam Al-Wakil
IFJ denounces Israel for blocking entry of journalists into Gaza
Postponing Trial Of Al Maidan Journalist To November 20
MB MP Condemns Assaulting Al Maidan Journalist
The Palestinian Journalists Forum calls for release of Journalists
IFJ Condemns Israeli Settlers’ Attack on Palestinian Journalists
Media forum and journalist bloc slam PA and Israel for arresting journalists
A year after Shaikh of Azhar call to lash journalists
Al-Dostour Calls For Protest Against Detaining Its Journalist
Rights Center Calls for Immediate Probe Into Assaults Against Journalists at Mansoura Hospital
Journalists Held Inside Al-Mansoura University, One Assaulted By University President
Egyptian journalists face the trials of September
Concluding the Investigations with the Journalists of Addustour and al Tariq and Releasing them from
Journalists challenge Egypt’s exceptional laws at seminar
Egypt sentences Muslim Brothers, journalists harassed
Rights Groups Call for Official Action against Torturing a Journalist
West Bank journalists detained by PA intelligence
Beltagi: Gov’t Journalists Lie!
Eight children, journalist among yesterday’s Gaza dead
Journalists and MB Supporters Harrassed Prior to Military Verdict
PJB: Crimes of PA security forces against journalists intolerable
Abbas’s authority record of crimes against journalists
Jordanian court passes jail terms on journalists for offensive article
Journalists stage protest in support of Muslim Brotherhood
Tunisia: Amnesty International condemns decision to uphold prison sentence against journalist
Report: 2007 Worst for Egyptian journalists
The American Media and Islam: A Journalists Opinion
Cases Against Bahraini Journalists Hit Record Highs
50 people, including journalists, arrested before Kefaya protest begins
Tunisia: Journalist , human rights activist banned traveled
Lawyers’ Demonstration Show Solidarity with Journalists, Call for Liberation of Egyptian Minds
Arab Rights Groups Condemn court ruling against Tunisian journalist Salim Boukhdir
Journalist, 8 Students to Prosecution