Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Thu93 2020

Last update18:06 PM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
:: Issues > Activites
Egypt’s Critics Have a Voice, but Never the Last Word
Egypt’s Critics Have a Voice, but Never the Last Word
In Egypt, there is relative freedom to complain about and criticize the government, even the feared security services. Egypt is not Syria in that way, or Saudi Arabia, where public criticism aimed at the state is often dealt with harshly
Thursday, February 19,2009 03:15
by Michael Slackman New York Times

In Egypt, there is relative freedom to complain about and criticize the government, even the feared security services. Egypt is not Syria in that way, or Saudi Arabia, where public criticism aimed at the state is often dealt with harshly.

But that is where freedom stops.

“I call it the freedom to scream,” said Fahmy Howeidy, a writer who has often criticized the government without penalty. “You can say what you want. But you cannot act.”

The detention this month of Philip Rizk, an Egyptian-German who organized a peaceful march in support of Palestinians in Gaza, received international attention because of his dual nationality and because he was held incommunicado and without charge.

But what made Mr. Rizk’s case extraordinary was how routine it actually was, according to political activists, political scientists, bloggers, Islamists, former prisoners and human rights groups here and abroad. It is all too common for the security services to grab citizens, detain them without charge, refuse to release any information concerning their whereabouts and deny them even the minimal protections, under an emergency law passed decades ago to help fight terrorism.

“In Egypt, it’s sort of a soft dictatorship,” said Gamal Eid, executive director of the Arabic Network for Human Rights Information in Cairo. “They want to have a pleasant image. But Egypt is ruled by the security apparatus.”

The security services appear to have decided that it is generally acceptable to write for a newspaper. But bloggers are another matter. For some reason, as yet unexplained, blogging seems to cross the line from speaking to acting.

It may be that bloggers, by nature, are less willing to stop at the edge of what criticism is tolerated. Newspaper writers, for example, are cautious about how they deal with the president; bloggers have often attacked him head-on.

Many bloggers have been arrested and beaten and thrown in jail. Mr. Eid said his organization was handling more than 100 cases of bloggers facing criminal charges. He keeps on his wall a snapshot of Abdul Kareem Nabeel Suleiman, a young blogger sentenced to four years in prison for criticizing President Hosni Mubarak and the state’s religious institutions.

Karim el-Beheiri is a blogger too. He is a nervous wreck. His legs don’t stop jumping, his eyes dart around, and he smokes three packs a day. He suffers memory loss and fatigue. He’s been that way since he was held without charge for 73 days by state security — even after a judge ordered his release.

Mr. Beheiri, 25, wrote about corruption and workers’ rights. He worked in a state-owned textile factory where tens of thousands of workers went on strike last April in a dispute with the government over wages. He said he had been beaten, shocked, handcuffed and manacled through much of his ordeal.

“For a second, after the judge said I should be freed, I thought there really were laws in this country,” Mr. Beheiri said, dragging on a cigarette.

Diaa Eddin Gad, 23, another blogger, was grabbed the same day as Mr. Rizk and has not been heard from since.

But there is a gray line through it all. The Muslim Brotherhood — a religious and social movement that wants to see Egypt ruled by Islamic law — is legally banned and its members are often arrested, even tried before military courts. But it has offices around the country and is allowed to operate religious and charitable activities.

There are some critics who say that the government allows the brotherhood to survive so that Egyptian officials can say to the West that they are fighting to keep the Islamists from power.

Still, 740 of its members were arrested because they protested in support of the Palestinians in Gaza.

“There is a red line: don’t make a big deal of your ideas,” said Nasser Hobshi, 42, an engineer, as he sat with friends at an outdoor cafe near the stock exchange.

There are laws on the books that provide for some degree of due process. Even the emergency law, which gives the government broad powers to ignore civil protections in the Constitution and to detain citizens without charge, requires the authorities to make public that a person was detained, legal experts here said. But, they say, the rules are often ignored, largely because the security forces operate with impunity.

There is also a belief among some political activists here that Egypt’s leaders think the new administration in Washington is too busy with the transition and the economic crisis to think much about repression in Cairo.

“It’s an old regime that doesn’t have the imagination to find new answers,” said Hassan Nafaa, a former political science professor at Cairo University. “This pattern of repression — it is not the result of a political vision; it is the product of a security apparatus.”

The government disputes the criticism. Gen. Hamdy Abdel Karim, a spokesman for the Interior Ministry, said: “None of these false allegations on the part of wrongdoers are going to stop me from exercising my authority to enforce stability and order. Anyone in trouble will try to justify his position.”

He added: “Your impression is wrong, wrong, wrong, because you’re listening to some bloggers. But to get the real general impression, you have to go back to the street and ask the people who deal with the police on a daily basis.”

Where better to ask than in bustling Falaki Square, where Sayed Mohammed, 50, had a cigarette in his mouth as he tinkered with the engine of his white Peugeot.

“Of course there are laws,” he said with a quick qualification: “Texts.”

“They say the people who go to jail are against the government,” he said. “But when you look at how the system works here, you see that it’s the government who is against the people.”

Nadim Audi contributed reporting

Posted in Activites , Human Rights  
Related Articles
Mishaal: Occupation is responsible if Egypt’s efforts fail
Ex-Egyptian foreign affairs official calls for isolating Israel internationally
Egyptian Truck Drivers Still on Strike amid Security Threats
Iran and the Muslim Brotherhood in Egypt?
Egypt’s Pharmacists Close Their Pharmacies as of Saturday
Egyptian Interior Min. Rounds up 36, Cairo Court Releases 270 Brotherhood Members
Egyptian MPs Lash Out at Denying Int’l Lawyers Access to Gaza
Egypt and Gaza after the war
Abu Marzouq: Egypt will announce the Tahde’a within 48 hours
Freed Egyptian protester describes ordeal, but fate of seized blogger is unknown
Parliamentarian: Egyptian Government Can’t Restore the Rights of Its Subjects Abroad
Thinking about Egypt
MB MP Slams Egyptian Probes With Palestinian War-Wounded
MB MP Condemns Egyptian Neglect of "Brotherhood" Ship Appeal
Egyptian Regime Planning to Subject Fatwa Law According to its Political Moods
Urgent Statement on More Bribes Given to Egypt ’s Ruling Party MPs
Egyptian Security Forces Disperse Rabia al-Adawiya’s Pro-Gaza Protest, Dozens Arrested
Egypt ’s Decison of Closing Rafah Crossing ’Stunning’: Habib
Egyptian lawyers want Israeli war criminals put on trial
Egyptian Authorities Prevents Delegations of Teaching Faculty Members from Entering Gaza
Egypt`s Muslim Brotherhood thanks Turkey’s Erdogan
Egyptian Bloggers and Journalists in the Hot Seat
Egypt installs cameras, censors on borders with Gaza
Egyptian company supplied IOF with food during war on Gaza
Egyptian Activities Demand Opening Rafah Crossing and Praise Resistance
A Classical Egyptian X-File: The grand Cairo fire
HRW accuses Israel, PA, and Egypt of suppressing pro-Gaza rallies
Widespread anger in Egypt at Mubarak regime
Facebook As a Platform for Anti-Establishment Protests in Egypt
Israeli Violations on Egyptian Territories: Eight Rockets, Seven Injured, 39 Cracked Houses
Egypt’s intelligence blackmails wounded Palestinians to tell about Hamas
Egypt Security Forces Assault, Detain Dozens Including Children Over Gaza Protests
Muslim Brotherhood Statement on Egyptian Gaza Initiative
Hundreds of Demonstrations In Egypt Protesting Israeli War Crimes in Gaza
Akef: The Egyptian-French initiative is an Israeli request
Egyptian National Forces: We Support Palestinians’ Right To Armed Struggle
Egypt Is Legally Obliged To Protect Gaza Civilians
Muslim Brotherhood Demands Egyptian Regime Take Positive Measures for Gaza
Egyptian Security Assault El-Behera Pro-Gaza Protest, 32 Women Injured
Egypt Police Block Friday Prayer, Assault Hundreds in Pro-Gaza Downtown Protests
Mubark and el-Shreef Tear Apart the MB
Muslim Brotherhood Messages Mubark
Mubark Vows Political and Legislative Reforms
The Brotherhood’s Respond to Gamal Mubark’s Statements