Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Tue109 2018

Last update19:14 PM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
New PPI Paper on US Policy toward the Middle East
New PPI Paper on US Policy toward the Middle East
While there is a well-deserved consensus that the Bush administration has caused untold damage to our relationship with the Arab and Muslim world, it would be a mistake to think that eight years of Republican rule are an anomaly in an otherwise proud history of successful engagement. The reality is more troubling: American policy has been consistently self-defeating under administrations of both parties for more than five decades...
Tuesday, October 21,2008 11:38
by Shadi Hamid Democracy Arsenal

The Progressive Policy Institute (PPI) has just released a paper of mine titled "Necessary Risks: How a New U.S. Administration Can--Finally--Give Us the Middle East Policy We Need." Here"s the intro. Here"s the full paper. This is a bit different than some of the previous things I"ve done which have focused specifically on the political Islam question. In this paper, I try to take a broader look at the assumptions that have driven U.S. policy over the last five decades under both Republicans and Democrats. More often than not, these assumptions have been misguided, sometimes dangerously so. I argue for a "re-orientation" of U.S. policy toward the region. Here are a couple excerpts:

America"s mounting failures in the Middle East are tied not only to ineffective policies but also--and perhaps more importantly--to faulty assumptions about the sources of our difficulties in the region. Anti-American violence and terrorism is fueled by long-standing grievances, both real and perceived. A new Middle East strategy must be premised on a long-term effort to seek out root causes of this anger and, where possible, address them...

While there is a well-deserved consensus that the Bush administration has caused untold damage to our relationship with the Arab and Muslim world, it would be a mistake to think that eight years of Republican rule are an anomaly in an otherwise proud history of successful engagement. The reality is more troubling: American policy has been consistently self-defeating under administrations of both parties for more than five decades...

From the perspective of millions of Arabs and Muslims, the United States is complicit in their repression and in the denial of democratic alternatives. Even the most unfair anti-American paranoia cannot be understood as a product of mere irrational hate. It is important for Americans to understand how valid grievances can snowball into a more general suspicion of all U.S. motives and actions—a suspicion that lends itself to disinformation and conspiracy theorizing. In short, most policy disagreements are substantive and many are legitimate. Even the ones that are not must be addressed on the plane of policy. Perceptions matter because they drive narratives, and narratives drive the way Middle Easterners view the United States.

Read the whole thing.


Posted in  
Add Comment Send to Friend Print
Related Articles
To be American and Muslim (it’s about time)
Can an Arab be a decent family man?
The Hypocrisy of (some) Arab Liberals
Let’s not talk about Saudi Arabia
Engaging the Middle East
How Much Does the Middle East Matter?
9/11: Facts and Narratives
The Boiling Point
A Moderate Islamist is Arrested in Egypt - and What it Means for Us
"I want to be an American" - Obama fever taking over Europe
The Need to Prioritize Elections
Yes We Can
America vs. Americans - how the rest of the world sees us
Bhutto says Bin Laden was Murdered?
The Nuclear Scenario in Pakistan
Thought Experiment - A Muslim Europe?
The NIE and Remembering Things Lost
Will an "Islamic Reformation" Ever Come?
To be an American Muslim?
The Worst Answer of Last Night’s Debate
Looking for Moderate Islamists
Re: Who’s to Blame for the Middle East’s Problems
Understanding the Retributive Impulse
Would Democracy in Morocco be a Good Thing?
How to Rig Elections without Rigging Them: The Case of Morocco
Condi Rice: Rhetoric vs. Policy
Democracy Promotion Needs a Plan of Action
Neoconservatism is Dead
The Problem of Modernity?
Supporting Dissidents in Egypt: Muslim Brotherhood, Ayman Nour
To Engage or Not to Engage?
Drop What You’re Doing and Read This
What Makes a Starbucksist (or how to fight Islamo-fascists with the power of our ideas)?
Maybe it’s Time to Start Getting Scared