Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Thu93 2020

Last update18:06 PM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
:: Opinions > Other Opinions
The Doha Debates
The Doha Debates
I took part last Wednesday in renowned broadcaster Tim Sebastian’s Doha Debates Show, which is shot in the Qatari capital and broadcast monthly on the BBC World channel.
Saturday, September 20,2008 10:01
by Amr Hamzawi Al-Masrey Al-Youm

I took part last Wednesday in renowned broadcaster Tim Sebastian"s Doha Debates Show, which is shot in the Qatari capital and broadcast monthly on the BBC World channel.


The show is exciting, as it is based on a debate between two teams of speakers on a certain issue. It is attended by an audience of those concerned with the issue and they vote for one team.


Democracy in the Arab world was the topic of the debate. Lebanese media personality Mai Shedyak and former Iraqi ambassador to Britain Salah al-Sheleikhi were of the viewpoint that democratic transformation is in full swing in several Arab countries.


I and Dr. Mustafa al-Hamarna, former director of the Jordanian University"s Strategic Studies Center, were on the other team. We underlined that the Arab world is witnessing deterioration in political and civil freedoms and an escalation in restrictions imposed on political competition.


Sebastian ran the debate with his usual technique that includes both quick questions and search for contradictions in proofs provided by speakers. Shedyak and Shekheili"s indicated that the vitality of the Arab street and the gradual reform steps in Arab societies were the best proof provided by their team.


Hamarna and I underlined that democracy has four unfulfilled components: transition of power, balance between legislative, judicial and executive institutions, ability to bring rulers to account and the presence of a real chance for peaceful opposition to reach power through ballots.


The audience intensively took part in the debate and had various comments. Some said the Arabs are still unready for democracy and others were convinced that democracy is a legitimate right and dream that has not been fulfilled yet.


On the other hand, the debate showed that the issue of democracy is not a top priority in the Arab world even if it figured high in the list of priorities. This was proved by recent opinion polls.


The top priorities nowadays are security and achieving a sufficient degree of progress that could ensure a decent life for the people. We should admit that we, as democracy advocates, failed so far to establish a link between society progress and democracy.


Almost two thirds of the audience voted for al-Hamarna and Hamzawi"s viewpoint that casts doubt on the Arab democratic transformation chances.


The debate ended with loud applause. We all applauded for our continuous inability to place the Arab societies on the road of democracy, the best system for managing the relation between the rulers and the ruled.




Posted in Other Opinions  
Related Articles
Democracy assistance - new world, new challenges
Democracy halted in Arab World, says Gulf debating forum
Morsi: Democracy Conforms To Islamic Shura
Democracy in Egypt
Islamist Parties and Democracy: Three Kinds of Movements
Long Live the Military’s Democracy!
Digital democracy: women activists making IT their own
Those Who Are Tasked to Police This Democracy Are Blinded by Confetti
Amr Hamzawi : Gamal Mubarak lacks legitimacy
Egypt State Security Cancels “Eye on Democracy” Show On Al Horra Satellite Channel
Are Arabs fit for democracy?
The uses of democracy
Egyptian Muslim Brother says Mauritania coup reflects crisis in Arab democracy
Jailed Nur urges Obama to back Arab democracy
Egypt: Govt Convicts Democracy Activist Saad Eddin Ibrahim
The US is colluding in the trampling of democracy in Egypt
Interview with Amr Hamzawy on The Egyptian Political Scene
Arab Islamists, their internal democracy
Is democracy a security issue?
POMED Notes: Islamist Parties and Democracy
Democracy Promotion in the Middle East: Restoring Credibility
EVENT on "Islamist Parties and Democracy"
Do Muslims deserve democracy?
Testimony on the United States and the Promotion of Human Rights and Democracy
Survey: Gulf Between Democracy in Theory and Practice
Political parties are the second face of democracy
Ellison spreads word in Egypt about benefits of U.S.-style democracy
Political Islam and Democracy - What do Islamists and Islamic Movements want?
Missing in Action: The Democracy Agenda in the Middle East
Democracy – Egyptian Style
No Democracy in the Arab World
Interview with Amr Hamzawy
Why Middle East democracy is inevitable
Amr Hamzawy: Policy Fusion
Democracy, Presidential Election and the Lobby
In Egypt, democracy is the only solution
Is Islam Compatible with Democracy?
Democracy – Egyptian Style
What’s Left of Bush’s Democracy Agenda?
Selling Democracy - De Lux Model with Double-Standards Built In
Habib Urges Arab Leaders to Embrace Democracy in Pursuit of Stability
Democracy Day in Pakistan Promises No Pardon for Musharraf
MB and democracy, again
Arrest of Muslim Brotherhood supporters illustrates limits to democracy in Egypt
No Brothers in Doha
US-Islamic World Forum Held in Doha in Absence of Muslim Brotherhood
Democratic Change in Egypt?-Amr Hamzawy and Others
Dr. Amr Hamzawy
Egyptian Parliamentary Elections: CNN interviews Amr Hamzawy
Doha Host of Pan-Arab and Islamic Conference
12 years of National Islamic cooperation under research in Doha