Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Thu93 2020

Last update18:06 PM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
:: Archive > MB in International press
Dude, We Didn’t Say That
Dude, We Didn’t Say That
The Muslim Brotherhood’s Official website has an interesting article on a recent piece that was falsely attributed to them.
Sunday, August 3,2008 06:38
by Grandmasta Arabicsource.Wordpress.com

The Muslim Brotherhood’s Official website has an interesting article on a recent piece that was falsely attributed to them. 

Nawaal  Sadawi is an Egyptian feminist intellectual who, to put it bluntly, says stuff that angers conservative Islamist movements.   In response to some recent statements, the Islamic Group (Al-Jama’a Al-Islamiyya) issued a statement calling for her to be prosecuted for blasphemy.  The Muslim Brotherhood, always trying to prove its credentials as a mainstream movement,  is angry, quite understandably, because a Lebanese publication attributed the statement to the Brotherhood, and not the Islamic Group.  This is a pretty inexcusable mistake from an editing standpoint because in either Arabic in English its pretty hard to confuse “Islamic Group” and “Muslim Brotherhood.”   

But what’s most interesting is the description at the bottom of the article.  Clearly not happy with this false link to the Islamic Group, the writer goes further to distinguish between the two groups:

“Jam”a Islamiya (Islamic Group)is a radical group devoted to overthrowing the Egyptian regime through violent Jihad (although some of its leaders officially renounced violence in 2002.) The Muslim Brotherhood currently calls for an Islamic state through democratic means.

In a reaction to MENASSAT’s article, Muslim Brotherhood Secretary General Mahmoud Essat said,” We promote the freedom of thought, and never in the history of the Muslim Brotherhood { have} we prosecuted or called for the prosecution of writers.”

These two groups are long-time rivals and its interesting to see how they view each other.  The Islamic Group views the Muslim Brotherhood as sell-outs who gave up their principles in pursuit of power in the corrupting political process.   By contrast, at least according to this piece, the Ikhwan views the Islamic Group as violent fanatics, and disputes their claim to have abandoned violence. 

Grandmasta has had numerous posts  on the Islamic Group’s Ideological revisions.  He thinks they are serious, and would not agree that they are committed to violent jihad as this Ikhwan piece says. That being said, there should be no illusions about where the Islamic Group stands in the ideological spectrum of the Islamist movement, as this piece illustrates.  They are still hard-core, extreme religious fundamentalists.   Dr. Esposito  might want to  hold off on sending them an invitation to the next inter-faith dialogue conference at the Prince Alaweed Bin Talal Center for Muslim-Christian Understanding.  Don’t waste money on postage;  they probaly don’t want to participate.  Still, hard-core fundamentalism is better than violent fanaticism.


Posted in MB in International press  
Related Articles
Ali El Din Helal criticizes Muslim Brotherhood’s vagueness
Menassat Correction: Jama’a Islamyia Not MB Called for Female Activist Prosecution
Ratification of Military Verdicts Is Worthless, says MP Sobhi Saleh
Stomping of Mubarak Visage Prompts Charge in Clampdown on Media
Is the Brotherhood a democratic organization?
Brotherhood MP says 25 percent of Egyptian legislation “unconstitutional”
Film chronicles history of Egypt’s judiciary
EGYPT: Muslim Brotherhood ’Stronger’ After Party Election
Egyptian PM Excludes Farouq Gewedah from the SCC
Egyptian Bloggers Condemn "Egyptian Stances" Campaign
Morsi: Neglecting Human Development is the Cause of Egypt’s Failure
Sawaseya Center Condemns Punishing Student for Criticizing the President
The Muslim Brotherhood is Pro-Dialogue, Engagement of Women and Copts : Habib
MB Chairman: Food crisis stems from corruption not overpopulation
Brotherhood deny reports of internal elections next month
Ikhwanweb Condemns the Arrest of its Editor by Egyptian Police
Media in Egypt opening up and getting clamped down
Reporting The Muslim Brotherhood
Test The New Admin Serve Dont Publish
A Pyramid of Choices
The Brotherhood opens up
Jamaa Islamiya for Presidential Election Before Year End
Release40.com Calls for Releasing MB Military Trial Detainees
Decades After Camp David, Resistance to Normalization Endures in Egypt
Press Release: Top-Down Political Reform in Arab World Prolongs Stagnation
The Untold Story of the Muslim Brotherhood
University students protest arrest of colleagues in Egypt
To Talk or Not To Talk?—That is The Question
Young Brothers in Cyberspace
MERIP 245: Politics of Youth
The Worst Answer of Last Night’s Debate
U.S. engages Muslim Brotherhood despite Rice
Egyptian media mogul defends hijab comment
The Brotherhood at a Crossroads
Outsourcing Torture
Egypt: Security, Political, and Islamist Challenges
The Muslim Brotherhood shows its true colors
Doing dialogue in Cairo
A Peace-maker behind Bars