Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Tue109 2018

Last update19:14 PM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
Charm offensive as Cairo comes to the Cape
Charm offensive as Cairo comes to the Cape
The Emergency Law is now used to impinge on individual privacy and freedoms. Besides barring demonstrations and public gatherings that are not approved by the government, it enables the security services to search and detain people without charge for prolonged periods and allows the prosecution of civilians in military courts.
Saturday, August 2,2008 22:19
by ZOLEKA NDAYI Mail & Guardian Online

President Hosni Mubarak"s historic visit to South Africa could have provided President Thabo Mbeki with an opportunity to discuss the need for democratic reforms in Egypt.

But in light of the economic deals that the two countries are expected to sign and Egypt"s offer to provide South Africa with much-needed human resource capital -- the question is whether Mbeki can afford to sacrifice urgent economic interests by criticising Mubarak on human rights abuses in Egypt.

Mbeki"s widely criticised strategy of quiet diplomacy in Zimbabwe has taken almost a decade to pave the way for negotiations for democratic rule in that country.

As in Zimbabwe, Egypt"s human rights record is one of the worst in the world. Mubarak like Robert Mugabe is one of the longest-serving presidents on the continent. Both were, at one time, heroes in their countries and in Africa at large.

But their unwillingness to relinquish power has led both men to use state machinery to suppress civil liberties.

Mubarak"s amendment of the Egyptian Constitution in July 2005, which allowed for multi-candidate presidential elections, and his announcement to scrap the Emergency Law by June 1 this year could be interpreted as turning points in Egyptian history and important strides towards democracy.

But these moves have not translated into tangible progress towards democratisation of the country. The low voter turnout of 23% in Mubarak"s fifth re-election in September 2005 and of 27% in the constitutional referendum of March 2007 reflect Egyptians" loss of hope.

Political party formation is still subject to government approval and the Emergency Law has not been scrapped in spite of Mubarak"s pledges to do so.

Egypt has been under a state of emergency since 1981. With the help of the Emergency Law the government managed to weed out terrorism after the assassination of Mubarak"s predecessor, Anwar al-Sadat, and to curb the anti-tourist terrorist attacks of the late 1990s.

The Emergency Law is now used to impinge on individual privacy and freedoms. Besides barring demonstrations and public gatherings that are not approved by the government, it enables the security services to search and detain people without charge for prolonged periods and allows the prosecution of civilians in military courts.

South Africa, with its strong stance against human rights abuses, may be expected to talk Mubarak into political reforms in Egypt.

But for now economic interests appear to prevail over political ones.

The two leaders were expected to witness the signing of a joint declaration of intent covering strategic cooperation in the fields of petroleum and natural gas.

Given the urgent need for skilled labour and the energy crisis, the nature of South Africa"s economic interest in Egypt seems to outweigh the need to push for political reforms.

Mbeki should be applauded for coaxing Mugabe to the negotiation table with Morgan Tsvangirai, leader of Movement for Democratic Change, despite the fact that it has taken him almost a decade to do so.

For the moment relations with Egypt should strike a good balance between securing good political and economic relations as well as a preamble that will set the tone for human rights reform.

Dr Zoleka Ndayi is an international relations lecturer at the University of the Witwatersrand


Posted in  
Add Comment Send to Friend Print
Related Articles
Mubarak hangs on
Mubarak visit clouded in secrecy :: What’s the Pharaoh doing in Pretoria?
Stomping of Mubarak Visage Prompts Charge in Clampdown on Media
Hisham Mubarak Law Center Criticizes Releasing Lawyers on Bail, Sparing Police Officers
Undermining Mubarak
Public March to Mubarak’s Palace Protesting Gas Exports to Israel
Mubarak’s own strike-free birthday gift
Egypt Opposition Increases Pressure on 80-Year old Mubarak
EGYPT: New Strike to Greet Mubarak
Egypt: Mubarak’s concessions lead to more resistance
Is Muslim Brotherhood Mubarak’s Real Fear
MENA: Abbas, Mubarak to meet on developments in Palestinian territories
Hunger Pains for Mubarak
Mahdi Akef: Muslim Brotherhood Rejects Gamal Mubarak as President
Egypt’s Muslim Brotherhood leader slams President Mubarak’s son
A birthday present for Mubarak
Responses to “Mubarak hangs on”
Mubarak hangs on
Egyptian Local Poll: Mubarak’s Games
Egypt’s doctors take on Mubarak
Masri: Abbas-Olmert meeting meant to foil Mubarak’s call
Mubarak under pressure
Top CEIP Researcher: US Has no View over Mubarak’s Possible Successor
Bush’s Double-Talk Fits Mubarak’s Egypt
President Bush Meets with President Hosni Mubarak of Egypt
Give it a break, Mr Mubarak
Barak attacks Mubarak after Palestinian pilgrims crossed Rafah terminal
5 Rights Groups Urge Mubarak Reopen Sudanese Refugees Probe
Mubarak Curbs Dissent, Paves Way for Next President (Update1)
Roger Cohen: Viva Mubarak, Fuera Chavez!
Mubarak rejects foreign pressure
Mubarak’s Son Denies Succession Move
Egypt ruling party keeps Mubarak
US-Egyptian relations post-Mubarak: Plus ca change...
Egypt’s Mubarak too weak to travel; son Gamal being groomed
Egypt’s media defy Mubarak at their peril
Hisham Qasim to Reuters: No Progress As Long As Mubarak Is in Power. No Reformists in NDP
Jailed Brotherhood leaders accuse Mubarak’s regime of politicizing the army
With tough moves, Egypt moves to ensure stability whenever post-Mubarak era dawns
Egyptian Opposition Paper Editor Stands Trial for Article on Mubarak’s Failing Health