Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Tue109 2018

Last update19:14 PM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
:: Issues > Iran
Ex-Advisers Warn Against Threatening to Attack Iran
Ex-Advisers Warn Against Threatening to Attack Iran
The Bush administration should stop talking about a military attack as an option if negotiations do not immediately halt Iran’s uranium reprocessing program, two former national security advisers said yesterday.
Wednesday, July 23,2008 07:53
by Walter Pincus WashingtonPost

The Bush administration should stop talking about a military attack as an option if negotiations do not immediately halt Iran"s uranium reprocessing program, two former national security advisers said yesterday.

"Don"t talk about "do we bomb them now or later?" " said Brent Scowcroft, adviser to presidents Gerald R. Ford and George H.W. Bush, during a discussion at the Center for Strategic and International Studies on the negotiations between the United States and Iran.

Scowcroft added that by mentioning that threat, "we legitimize the use of force . . . and may tempt the Israelis" to carry out such a mission. He said he thinks that negotiations must continue and that sanctions have had an effect on Tehran, noting that even with elevated oil prices, Iran, alone among oil producers, is having a difficult time economically.

Zbigniew Brzezinski, adviser to President Jimmy Carter, described the Bush administration"s policy of maintaining the option of military action as "counterproductive."

"I don"t want the public to believe a preemptive attack can be justified," he said. Repeating the possibility "convinces Iran it is being threatened . . . and maybe it ought to have a [nuclear] weapon."

He added that a U.S. attack on Iran would be a "disaster," suggesting it could result in the U.S. fighting "for at least two decades" on four fronts -- Iraq, Iran, Afghanistan and Pakistan.

Brzezinski said he fears that if negotiations break down between now and the end of the year, some in the Bush administration might believe "it justifies doing something."

Both former advisers said they think both Washington and Tehran are internally divided on how to proceed, making progress difficult before the next U.S. president takes office. But they said that President Bush"s sending Undersecretary of State William J. Burns to the most recent negotiations with Iran was a positive step.

"It brings the U.S. solidly in with the Europeans and the Russians," Scowcroft said.

Both also said there are parallels between negotiations with Iran and previous talks with North Korea on its nuclear programs. One difference is the role of China: Scowcroft pointed out that the Chinese, once engaged in the North Korea discussions, were "decisive" because Beijing has enormous economic leverage over Pyongyang.

China does not have similar influence over Iran. Scowcroft said that in partnership with the Germans, the two "could affect the Iran negotiations."


Posted in Iran  
Add Comment Send to Friend Print
Related Articles
Iran holds key to India’s energy insecurity
Top U.S. military officer assails Iran’s role in Iraq
Joint Chiefs Chairman Says U.S. Preparing Military Options Against Iran
Iran agrees to discuss alleged nuclear weapons program
Iran’s nuclear progress stuns West
Source: U.S. Strike on Iran Nearing
Al Qaeda to Iran
Manageable chaos in Iraq suits Iran
Iran joined militias in battle for Basra
The Folly of Attacking Iran
The 1953 CIA Coup in Iran and the Roots of Middle East Terror
Who leaked the details of a CIA-Mossad plot against Iran?
Patience Is the Best Iran Policy
1st Phase of Iran Oil Bourse Inaugurated on Kish Island
The Increasing Encirclement of Iran
Iran’s Clerical Old Guard Being Pushed Aside
Researching and Writing about Human Rights in Iran
U.S. heading to war in Iran, says former inspector
Bush Admits He Plans to Attack Iran ?
Is It Really So Hard to Believe That Iran Stopped Its Nuclear Weapons Program?
Is It Really So Hard to Believe That Iran Stopped Its Nuclear Weapons Program?
Yemeni, Iranian presidents extend condolences to Haneyya
Why U.S. strategy on Iran is crumbling
Bush insists Iran biggest terror sponsor
Preparations for War with Iran?
Bush says US, allies must confront Iran
Bush warns Gulf Arabs of Iran threat
Gause: Saudis ‘Very Anxious’ to Hear Bush Views on Iran
U.S. says Iranian gunboats harassed warships
Army chief: Israeli military preparing for nuclear Iran scenario
Iran Can Help End the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict
Experts received MB program: call for religious state, Iranian-style
War Against Iran and the Logic of Dominance
Was a Covert Attempt to Bomb Iran with Nuclear Weapons foiled by a Military Leak?
Is Bush planning an attack on Iran?:
Al-Hashemi to Ikhwanweb: Iran Main Player in Iraqi Scene
US Gives Up Reform In Egypt, Forges Anti Hamas & Iran Alliance