Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Thu93 2020

Last update18:06 PM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
US democracy push makes Middle East liberals cringe
US democracy push makes Middle East liberals cringe
The United States sees itself as a beacon for democratic values, but Iranian and Arab reformers say its policies in the Middle East too frequently belie its ideals, making U.S. support for their cause a damaging liability.
Thursday, October 4,2007 08:24
by Alistair Lyon Reuters

The United States sees itself as a beacon for democratic values, but Iranian and Arab reformers say its policies in the Middle East too frequently belie its ideals, making U.S. support for their cause a damaging liability.

Repressive governments in the region, whether close allies or sworn foes of the United States, often exploit anti-American sentiment to accuse homegrown liberals of being stooges peddling a U.S.-Israeli agenda. Islamist movements do the same.

Accordingly, rights activists strive to distance themselves from U.S. actions in the Arab and Muslim world.

"Far from helping the development of democracy, U.S. policy over the past 50 years has consistently been to the detriment of the proponents of freedom and democracy in Iran," Iranian dissident Akbar Ganji, who spent six years in jail, wrote in an open letter to U.N. Secretary-General Ban Ki-Moon last month.

Ganji"s letter was mainly an appeal for the United Nations to condemn "intolerable" human rights violations in Iran.

But he prefaced it by saying U.S. President George W. Bush"s approval of funds to promote democracy in his country had "made it easy for the Iranian regime to describe its opponents as mercenaries of the U.S. and to crush them with impunity".

Even speaking about a possible military attack on Iran, he added, makes life tough for Iranian human rights campaigners.

Iran has been at bitter odds with the United States since the 1979 Islamic revolution, but liberals in Egypt, which gets about $2 billion a year in U.S. aid, echo Ganji"s thoughts.

"The United States under Bush has done great disservice to our struggle," veteran Egyptian sociologist and human rights activist Saadeddin Ibrahim told Reuters in Beirut this week.

"I welcome anyone who will lend a hand, but given America"s record in this region and its image as an arrogant superpower that is one-sided when it comes to Israel, there is a negativity that makes their endorsement of democracy backfire on those of us who have been fighting for it since Bush was in shorts."

Ibrahim, arrested in Cairo in 2000 ahead of Egyptian parliamentary elections, was acquitted of all charges against him in 2003, but is now in self-imposed exile fearing re-arrest.


Ten Egyptian journalists received jail sentences last month as part of an apparent crackdown on dissent as Egypt prepares for an inevitable transition from President Hosni Mubarak, 79.

Gamila Ismail, the wife of jailed Egyptian opposition leader Ayman Nour and a senior leader of his liberal al-Ghad party, said her husband"s supporters were accused of being Western agents whenever foreign powers called for his release.

She said the Bush administration"s initial enthusiasm for political reform in Egypt had soured. "Because of other interests in the region, we went down the list and I don"t think they are serious now about reform and democracy."

Rights activists see U.S. funding for democracy promotion in countries like Iran and Syria as at worst a thinly disguised stab at "regime change" or at best a token gesture.

"(U.S.) money is not going to help the democratisation process here," said Ebrahim Yazdi, Iran"s first post-revolution foreign minister and leader of the banned Freedom Movement.

Last year"s launch of a U.S. fund to assist democracy in Syria prompted Damascus to declare all American activities in the country "radioactive", creating hardships for U.S. private foundations engaged in educational and development work.

Andrew Tabler, an American who edits the English-language monthly Syria Today, lamented the harm to U.S.-Syrian contacts.

"There might be a struggle between the two administrations, but Americans must find new ways of engaging with Syrians and showing them what it is we"re all about," he said. For many Arabs and Iranians, Washington"s image suffers from its perceived selectivity towards democracy and human rights, as well as its support for Israel and its invasion of Iraq.

"The United States has lost a lot of its credibility on human rights because of Guantanamo, Abu Ghraib and renditions," said Nadim Houry of the U.S.-based Human Rights Watch group.

"They would regain some if they could show consistency in criticising not only regimes they don"t like in Iran and Syria, but also their allies like Jordan or Egypt."

U.S. shortcomings, however, were no excuse for Arab governments to discredit pro-democracy groups, Houry added.

Hostility to U.S. policies runs so deep that even Arab allies of Washington are loathe to be too closely identified with their patron, argued Beirut-based commentator Rami Khouri.

"So we are seeing the worst consequences of this tradition of American double standards and Arab hypocrisy."

Khouri cited the U.S. and European boycott of Hamas after its Palestinian election win as the "death knell" for Western advocacy of democratic rule in the Arab and Muslim world.

"If you want to promote democracy, do it consistently, not promote elections in one country and not in another," he said. (Additional reporting by Fredrik Dahl in Tehran and Alaa Shahine in Cairo)

Posted in  
Related Articles
Would Democracy in Morocco be a Good Thing?
Is Spreading Democracy in Middle East a Bad Idea?
Democracy, not terror, is the engine of political Islam
Democracy under siege
U.S. Democracy Promotion During and After Bush
How to Not Spread Democracy
Undermining Democracy in the Middle East
Democracy can make democrats
Democracy in the Middle East: A Dangerous Idea?
A Conversation Continued: Democracy and Demagoguery in the Middle East
The Middle East’s titanic battle
Rice sees ’rapid change’ occurring throughout Middle East
Why Are Liberals So Weak In Middle East?
Why Are Liberals So Weak In Middle East? By Judith Apter Klinghoffer
Democratization in the Middle East – A Role for the US Government?
Democracy and Rule of Law Middle East Series, Egypt
Push for Middle East democracy benefiting Islamists
Rising Islamist tide in Middle East politics
Interview with Research Director at Saban Center for Middle East Policy
Full text of Middle East ’road map’
Democracy and Stability in the Middle East
The Scope of Clashes in the Middle East Since 9/11
MPs’ Letter to European Parliament On The Middle East Crisis
Rabbi M. Lerner: End the Suffering in the Middle East
All Hell Breaks Loose in the Middle East
Muslim Brotherhood Criticizes Middle East Conference In Rome
Middle East: Al Qaeda takes a back seat
Blood borders, How a better Middle East would look
Brothers in Arms, EU Arms Exports in the Middle East
Call for Immediate Ceasefire in the Middle East
A Collective Failure In the Middle East
New Middle East, But Angry, Islamic and Democratic One
Blogs on the Middle East Crisis, When More Than Just Weapons Speak
Former Italian PM: Stability in Middle East hinges on settling the Palestinian question
MIDDLE EAST: Human rights abuses in Egypt, Iraq, Jordan and Syria
The U.S. Has Abandoned Reformists In The Middle East
Radical Middle Way Podcast launched with lectures from Shaykh Hamza Yusuf, Habib Ali and others
MIDDLE EAST: Weekly wrap of human rights violations in the region
Promoting Middle East Democracy II: Arab Initiatives
Carter Discusses New Book on Israel and the Middle East
U.S. Stays an Unsteady Course to Middle East Peace and Democracy
Jeffrey Blankfort: My years of Middle East Activism: An Interview
America’s Moment in The Middle East is About to End
For the U.S., the old Middle East was much better
Bloggers being watched in the Middle East.
Democratization of the Middle East
Saudi Arabia, Egypt and the Middle East: With friends like these
The ’New Middle East’ Bush Is Resisting
Is Democracy in the Middle East a Pipedream?
The Bush administration’s new strategy of setting the Middle East aflame
Lebanon and the Middle East crisis
Internet Freedom in the Middle East: Challenges for U.S. Policy
Time for war or peace in the Middle East?
Democratic backsliding in Middle East addressed at NED/CSID event
Middle East bloggers click for change
The Rise of Islamists in the Middle East
America Is Losing The Middle East Also
Robert Satloff: Promoting a Balanced Understanding of the Middle East
Comparing Political Inherency in America and the Middle East
Middle East: Egyptian Democrat Optimistic About Region’s Democratic Prospects
Seething Anger in a Broken Middle East
Thus are reports about the Middle East are generated
Should America Fear Middle East Democracy?
Promoting Democracy and Human Rights in the Middle East: The Case of Saudi Arabia
Our second biggest mistake in the Middle East
The New Middle East By Richard N. Haass
Bush’s crusade to bring democracy to the Middle East is resulting in strengthening militant Islam
Bush’s dream of democratic Middle East
Middle East Democracy
Ruling But Not Governing: Militaries in the Middle East