Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Sun1123 2014

Last update05:30 AM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
:: Issues > Torture
Egypt tortures for the US, so why not on its own account?
Human rights cannot be regional or selective: Guantanamo, Belmarsh, Laz Oghli and Facility 1391 stand or fall together The story of Maajid Nawaz, Ian Nisbet and Reza Pankhurst, the three British Muslims who travelled to Egypt with their families, their detention there, their trial and their release now, almost four years later, encapsulates several elements in the "east-wes
Thursday, March 9,2006 00:00
by Ahdaf Soueif, Guardian

Human rights cannot be regional or selective: Guantanamo, Belmarsh, Laz Oghli and Facility 1391
stand or fall together

The story of Maajid Nawaz, Ian Nisbet and Reza Pankhurst, the three British Muslims who travelled to Egypt with their families, their detention there, their trial and their release now, almost four years later, encapsulates several elements in the "east-west" or "war on terror" story. Media coverage in the UK has focused on the men’s Britishness and whether the British government did enough to help them. As usual, events outside the western hemisphere are presented as though in a void. So here’s a pencilling in of the local background.
Twenty-six young men were arrested in Cairo and Alexandria on April 1 2002, accused of membership of a banned group. This was not an extraordinary event. Over the past three decades, such arrests, detentions and kidnappings have become fairly common. People disappear. Friends hunt for them. Usually they are in the State Security Investigation Bureau in Laz Oghli Square in Cairo. They are generally held long enough to extract a confession. Their treatment ranges from insults, threats and beatings to fairly evolved methods of torture. Sometimes the person is not required to confess to anything; they are given a warning and let go.

Sometimes the person dies. Mostly, they are sent to jail to await trial. Once in jail, they are generally not ill-treated, but conditions are basic. There are about 15,000 political detainees in Egyptian jails. Some have been found innocent years ago. Some have never been brought to trial. Some have been there more than a decade. The young men arrested in April 2002 were accused of membership of the banned and avowedly non-violent Islamist group, Egyptian Hizb ut-Tahrir. Among them were the three Britons. They were members of British Hizb ut-Tahrir - a group that is not (yet) illegal.

The defence team for the men consisted of 15 Egyptian lawyers from across the political spectrum; from Muntassir el-Zayyat, eminent legal counsel of the Muslim Brotherhood, to Ahmad Sayf, popular leftwing head of the Legal Aid Centre, who served pro bono along with two lawyers from the Civil Liberties Committee of the bar association.

The case was tried in the state security emergency court, part of the apparatus supporting the emergency laws. These laws were first introduced to Egypt by the British occupying power during the first world war. They were reinstated, again by the British, for the second world war - and successive governments have used them as an instrument of oppression ever since. The state security emergency courts allow no further legal recourse - their decisions are not open to appeal, except directly to the president. Some are seen as vulnerable to political pressure. The dismantling of the emergency laws is a central demand of the opposition movements, which made their presence felt in the streets and in elections last year.

The evidence seized from the men’s homes took a year to examine. It was mainly books and articles, many published by the prestigious al-Ahram Centre for Political and Strategic Studies, by mainstream publishers and by human rights organisations. Submitted to the court were some 200 reports from the Higher Council for Islamic Affairs, the state adjudicator on religious matters on the religious content of the material - all declaring it innocent.

Sayf (who has himself spent time in jail) is convinced that none of the young men did more than discuss and publicise theoretical ideas about alternative forms of government. I attended a summing-up session at court, in June 2003. Here are the impressions I noted down that night: "Reza Pankhurst’s Iranian mother and English father are here. There’s a lot of sympathy for them as foreigners and parents - their lad caught up in this mess ... What struck me was the difference between the accused and the rest of us: the security, the relatives, even the lawyers looked worn, dusty and frayed. Inside the cage, the young men were collected and dignified ... Mrs Pankhurst said to me: ’I get my strength from him, from Reza’ ... The judge, Ahmad Izzat al-Ashmawi, has clearly lost patience with the prosecution. He declared that he will deliver his verdict on December 25. Everyone believes he will throw the case out."

On December 22, Egypt’s foreign minister, Ahmad Maher, paid a highly unpopular visit to Jerusalem. On a visit to the al-Aqsa mosque, shoes and slippers were thrown at him and some of his attackers managed to slap him. The Egyptian media blamed the Palestinian Hizb ut-Tahrir. In Cairo, Judge Ashmawi postponed declaring the verdict for three months. On March 25 2004, he declared the men guilty and handed down sentences ranging from one to five years.

Egypt is an important regional power. It is critical to US and British policy in the region: officially the spreading of democracy. But a real democracy in Egypt may not deliver what people perceive to be US and British aims: to secure strategic and economic interests, push ferocious free-market "reforms" and promote Israel. So the US and Britain support the status quo and its apparatus, while offering patronising lip-service to democracy.

The debate about whether the British government did enough to help its citizens is disingenuous. Why should Egyptian authorities pay heed to British ones? In Britain, we allow extraordinary rendition flights to stop-over in torture trips. The prime minister calls Guantلnamo an "anomaly". He appoints to the Foreign Office a lawyer who advised Israel to block a UN investigation into Israeli army activities in Jenin. In Egypt, our government tortures - presumably - at the behest of the US. Why not, then, on its own account?

Egypt’s judges are convening on March 17 to demand, yet again, the reinstatement of the judiciary’s independence. Opposition voices have called on citizens to hold a vigil in their support.

The 23 Egyptians and Palestinians arrested and jailed along with Nawaz, Nisbet and Pankhurst are still in detention. They remain, according to their lawyers and to precedent, subject to torture. The young sister of one of the Palestinians is dying in a Jerusalem hospital. Her hope of survival is a bone marrow transplant for which the only candidate is her willing brother. And he doesn’t even have a Tony Blair to not speak up for him.

Human rights cannot be regional. The rule of law cannot be selective. Guantلnamo, Belmarsh, Laz Oghli and Facility 1391 in Israel are part of the same configuration; they stand together or - one hopes - fall together.

 

· Ahdaf Soueif’s latest book is Mezzaterra, Fragments from the Common Ground


Posted in Torture , Other Opinions , Human Rights , Prisoners of Conscience  
Add Comment Send to Friend Print
Related Articles
Outsourcing Torture
Egyptian bloggers expose horror of police torture
The Un-American Way of Torture
Egyptian bloggers expose horror of police torture
Promises of Hunting Torture Suspected Officers in Al Fayyum Victim’s Conference
Al Fayyum Police Torture Citizen to Death, Families Refuses to Take Body
Hamido Tortured to death by Egyptian Police
New Torture Incident Committed by Egyptian Police
"Egyptians against Torture" to Kick off
Exclusive to Ikhwanweb, Video showing the tortured child -Mohamed Mamdouh-
Aljazeera.net Poll: Torture in Egypt a Systematic Policy
12 yrs Child Tortured to Death by Policemen
When will torture in Egypt end?
Giza Citizen Tortured, Killed
Islamists accuse Egypt police of kidnap, torture
New Torture Case in New Cairo Police Station
Egyptian Police Torture Dakahlia Citizen to Death
The Torture of 6 Boys,Kafr Alzayat,Gharbia
The Brotherhood’s Legislatives Launch a Severe Campaign on Torture
Calls for Combating Torture at Police Stations
The Interior Minister Faces Inquiry on Torture
Justice Ministry Admits Torture Cases
The Egyptian Parliament Tackles Torture Issues
The Brotherhood’s MP Asks for Reply on Torture Instance
New Torture Scandal in Police Stations
New Episode of Torture in Police Stations
Egypt tortures for the US, so why not on its own account?
Torture and Silence: This Year’s Arab Spring?
Egypt: AOHR Discusses Prison Torture Crimes Before Parliament
Protests Planned In Response To Alleged Torture
Popular Tribunal To Try Police Officers Accused of Torture
Who Stands behind torture in Egypt ?
Int’l of Torture: The Documents the Crown Would Like to Censor
Israel Plans Torture Center for Abducted Lebanese
PA Minister: PLC speaker was tortured by Israelis
EOHR: 81 Died Under Torture in Police Custody in 5 Years
Palestinian Abductees: Torture Expression of Jewish Sadism
Sinai torture fields
Torture by degrees
Torture videos to be investigated?
Egypt: Citizen Tortured by State Security Agents in Al Fayyum
Egypt: MB Condemns Tortures Against Members in Menoufeya
FEATURE-Egypt Internet video sharpens torture debate
HRW to Egypt: Hold Police Accountable for Torture
Al-Wadi Al-Gadid Detainees commit suicide to escape torture
An Egyptian Police Torture Story
Boulaq torturers to be tried 9 January
Egyptian police torture woman detainee (Videos)
Amnisty International: Four Tunisians risk torture on return
Partial Blacklist of Egyptian Police Officers Accused of Torture
Salsabeel Comp. Detained Employees Released after State Security Tortures
Torture victim receives 3 months in prison for “resisting authorities”!
Torture Me If You Can
Egypt bloggers reveal new torture case
Bloggers, Kifaya and Ikhwanweb Against Torture
El-Adly Video-Gate: Imbaba Police Detain Torture Victim’s Father
Egyptian Security Storms House of Torture Victim, Detains Wife, Father
Egypt: Officer Who Tortured, Killed Citizen Appears Before Trial Today
Torture video sparks outrage
Yet another face of torture
Tortured then Threatened to keep quite
These Moderates Are in Fact Fanatics, Torturers and Killers
Man claims torture in Egypt after refugee claim turned down
Ghost Plane: The True Story of the CIA Torture Program
263 Torture Cases in Egyptian Police Stations in 6 Yrs: Rights Organization
The US psychological torture system is finally on trial
New Torture Video Revealed In Egypt
Egypt in the dock over tactics of police torturers
Egyptian MP: Torture Is Systematic Under Current Regime
Egypt: Citizen Handicapped in Upper Limbs Due to Prison Torture
Bloggers and Rights Activists Against Torture Meeting
HRW to Mubarak’s regime: Investigate police torture, rape of blogger Sharqawi
Fighting Torture with Mobile Phones and Weblogs
Anti-torture activists: Mubarak’s police knows no limit
Tortured 11 Yrs Ago In Egypt
MPs Accuse Gov’t of Turning Police Stations Into Torture Centers
Saudi Arabia: New Video Confirms Torture in Prison
Brotherhood Parliamentarian Demands Ousting Interior Minister Over Torture
Egypt: TV journalist detained for denouncing torture
State Security Detains, Tortures 8 Al-Azhar Students
Security Forces Torture, Sexually Harass Luxor Family
Egyptian Citizen Tortured To Death Inside Police Station
Kafr Al-Sheikh Brotherhood Member Tortured By SSF
Gharbiya Citizen Tortured Till Deafness
Egypt Joins Human Rights Council... With More Tortures
Police Tortured MB Students During Thier Detention
A Visit to Fatah’s Torture Chamber
El-Adly Audiogate: Confessions of a Police Torturer
Egypt’s Tortures: Whole Family Tortured in Sharqiya
Abu Zuhri: Gaza Detentions, Tortures Groundless Claims
Egypt: Gov’t Blocks Ikhwanweb After Exposing Torture Cases
State Security Arrest, Torture Son Of Dakahlia Detainee
Egyptian report denounces torture
The Fourth Anniversary of the Torture of Detainee #25
Torture Victim Kidnapped To Prevent Airing His Story On TV Show
MB MP Accuses Interior Ministry of Turing Police Stations Into Torture Centers
Call for release of blogger who reports on torture of detainees
Defendants In Al Azhar Explosions Case Accuse Gov’t of Torture
Torture did not break him, so they detained him again
Egyptian Interior Ministry Acknowledges Police Torture Cases
More Torture Victims In Egypt
Tortured Tunisian Sends Message from Prison