Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Tue92 2014

Last update03:53 AM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
:: Arab Revolutions > EGYPT
Constitutional Scholar Atef Al-Banna: True Democracy Requires Real Conviction
Constitutional Scholar Atef Al-Banna: True Democracy Requires Real Conviction
Scores of legal and constitutional scholars and experts assert that Egypt’s newly elected constituent panel, entrusted to draw up the country’s new constitution, is balanced and represents all segments, classes, hues and denominations of the Egyptian public.
Thursday, March 29,2012 14:59
IkhwanWeb

 Dr. Atef Al-Banna, constitutional scholar and member of the Constituent Assembly to draft the constitution, said that current frenzied debate about the constituent committee, with some claiming that it is not expressive of all the Egyptian people, and some members withdrawing from the new panel, "are gratuitous and unnecessary arguments. The reasons given by those pulling out do not make sense.


“The Constituent Assembly does represent all segments of society: legal communities, trade unionists, workers, farmers, women, Muslims, Christians, and all", he added.


Dr. Al-Banna stressed that what panel protestors now are doing is the result of dissatisfaction with true democracy which requires that we accept the people's choice, like what’s already been settled in the March 2011 referendum which gave the elected members of parliament the responsibility of selecting the constituent committee to write the constitution.

The constitutional expert strongly criticized what he called “promoting zero-sum politics, and claiming that the constitution is what creates state institutions – as some media outlets have been saying, while in fact, the constitution regulates the work of institutions”.

Dr. Atef Al-Banna added that both chambers of parliament exercised their right to elect the Constituent Assembly with complete impartiality, but wondered why anyone should imagine that the minority must replace the majority.

Further, Dr. Al-Banna rejected the idea of forming parallel committees for writing the Constitution, pointing out that this violates constitutional and legal legitimacy. He added that the dispute over the new constitution pertains to only a couple of articles, pointing that the absence of real disputes over most articles of the constitution allows for harmony and broad consensus.

Moreover, the constitutional scholar explained that such hoped for harmony, compatibility and consensus do not necessarily mean a 100% unanimous decision, but that discussions, however, can reconcile differences and bring views closer. He reiterated that the majority of Constitution articles are not in dispute.
tags: Constitution / Muslims / Christians / Protestors / Parliament / Media / Constituent Assembly / Democracy / Atef Al-Banna / Egyptian People
Posted in EGYPT  
Add Comment Send to Friend Print
Related Articles
Freedom and Justice Party Delegation Visits UK
Justice Tariq Al-Bishri: Charter Writing Constituent Assembly Balanced
Freedom and Justice Parliamentary Commission Statement on Constituent Assembly Election
Freedom and Justice Party Executive Office Statement - Sunday, 25 March 2012
Consultation Hearings to Be Held Before Writing Constitution
Al-Bishri: Parliament Legally Entitled to Allocate Proportions of Constituent Assembly
Muslim Brotherhood Statement on Obstacles Hindering Power Handover to Elected Civilians
Egyptian Parliament Elects Members of Constituent Assembly of Constitution
Dr. Helmi Gazzar: Democracy Will Triumph, Culminating in Writing Constitution
Beltagy: Differences Over Constituent Assembly Exaggerated
Democracy, Between Faith and Practice, Words and Action
1000 Nominees for Egypt’s Constituent Assembly to Write New National Charter
The Freedom and Justice Party Views on Current Events
Freedom and Justice Party Chairman Urges Pakistan Pressure to Halt Assad Syrian Massacres
Egyptian Judiciary Refutes Constituent Assembly Invalidity Claims
Osama Yassin: FJP Tabled Comprehensive Plan for Advancement of Youth in All Areas
Dr. Morsi, Dutch Ambassador in Cairo: Egypt Deserves Urgent International Economic Aid
Dr. Morsi: New Constitution to Safeguard Freedoms, Rights
In Response to ElBaradei’s Comment, Law Experts Assert Constituent Assembly All-Inclusive, Parliament Fully Legitimate
Constituent Assembly Drafting Egyptian Constitution to Include 50% from Parliament, 50% from Outside Sources