Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Wed101 2014

Last update02:49 AM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
:: Issues > Activites
Debating Democracy in the Obama Era
Debating Democracy in the Obama Era
I wrote last month about an open letter, which I’ve helped organize, on the need to make democracy in the Middle East a top priority, which was signed by leading American and Muslim scholars and experts. The Washington Post, in an editorial, cited it, saying "[the letter’s] depth and breadth vividly shows that the Obama administration could find many allies for progressive change in the Middle East - if only it looks beyond the rulers’ palaces."
Thursday, April 9,2009 19:29
by Shadi Hamid Democracy Arsenal

I wrote last month about an open letter, which I"ve helped organize, on the need to make democracy in the Middle East a top priority, which was signed by leading American and Muslim scholars and experts. The Washington Post, in an editorial, cited it, saying "[the letter"s] depth and breadth vividly shows that the Obama administration could find many allies for progressive change in the Middle East - if only it looks beyond the rulers" palaces."

Tarek Osman, at OpenDemocracy, offered several critiques of the letter here. I"ve written a response, addressing the open letter"s aims and addressing the concerns of Osman and others:

But Osman is sceptical that there can ever be a rapprochement between America and Islamists, even those like the Muslim Brotherhood that are nonviolent. The United States, he rightly points out, is not so concerned with whether the Brotherhood is sufficiently democratic or whether it accepts the rights of women and minorities. The source of enmity, rather, is a clash of interests. "Pax Americana", Osman argues, "aims to ‘stabilise the region"", and this, of course, includes guaranteeing Israel"s security. Meanwhile, "Islam"s opposition is not time-bound but theological: it sees ‘settling" as a sin, and long-term jihad...is divinely ordained."

Osman is right that Israel is a major sticking-point, but he paints both America and Islamists in simplistic terms: as unitary, intransigent actors. Between and within Islamist movements, an important debate is taking place regarding the Jewish state. It may be true that individual Islamists harbour a religiously motivated hatred of Israel, but it is also true that beliefs are not always an accurate predictor of behaviour.

You can read the whole thing here.

The Source


Posted in Activites , Human Rights , Obama  
Add Comment Send to Friend Print
Related Articles
Democracy’s time: a reply to Tarek Osman
Democracy Digest: Event
It was Never about Democracy
How to Promote Democracy?
To Engage or Disengage...That is the Question?
Democracy Promotion in the Aftermath of Iraq
The US can promote democracy, smartly
Democracy-support and the Arab world: after the fall
POMED Notes: Democracy and Conflict
Scholars Urge Obama to Push for Democracy in Middle East
Anxiety And Engagement
Democracy and the Muslim world: the “post-Islamist” turn
Democracy Support in the Middle East
Open Letter to President Obama about Democracy Promotion in the Middle East and the Muslim World
Bi-Partisan Group of Prominent Scholars and Experts Urge President Obama to Make Democracy
Democracy the antidote to jihadist radicalization, task force concludes
Reclaiming The Mantle Of Democracy Promotion
Al Baradie’s Call to the Government to Engage MB
How democracy loses its footing in Middle East
How small steps can pave the way to democracy in the Middle East
Digital Democracy in Chile and Egypt
Democracy ‘normalizes’ Islamists?
Democracy in Palestine
Promoting democracy, not regime change
The Case for Democracy Promotion
A New Wave of Democracy
New Canadian democracy assistance agency on the way
Democracy Promotion in U.S. Foreign Policy
Should liberals promote liberal democracy?
Obama’s win promotes democracy in Arab world
‘Seismic’ economic shifts challenging democracy assistance
Re: The False Hope of Democracy Promotion
Islamist Parties and Democracy: Going Back to the Origins
Major Challenge to Arab Democracy
Funding GONGOs against democracy
Rare Victory for Muslim Democracy
Democracy assistance - what works?
Economic crisis could turn democracy’s stagnation into retreat, report warns
Democracy in Egypt, One Text and Twitter at a Time
Demanding Arab democracy
Syrian democracy activists face 15 years in prison
American Islamic Congress Hosts Capitol Hill Forum on Democracy and the Future of HR in Egypt
Islam and Democracy
The Muslim Brotherhood is Pro-Dialogue, Engagement of Women and Copts : Habib
Islamist Pragmatists Ripe for Engagement?
U.S. engages Muslim Brotherhood despite Rice
Engaged to Hamas
To Engage or Not to Engage?
We Must Engage With Moderate Muslims
Political Islam: Ready for Engagement?
Engagement or Quarantine: How to Deal with the Islamist Advance
View from Dubai: Why the West must engage Islamists