Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Wed423 2014

Last update18:02 PM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
Democracy Promotion in the Middle East: Restoring Credibility
Democracy Promotion in the Middle East: Restoring Credibility
U.S. democracy promotion efforts in the Middle East should focus on realistic political reform goals that correspond both to regional realities and the limited degree of actual U.S. influence.
Tuesday, July 22,2008 03:47
by Marina Ottaway Carnegie Endowment

U.S. democracy promotion efforts in the Middle East should focus on realistic political reform goals that correspond both to regional realities and the limited degree of actual U.S. influence. The most pressing issue facing Arab countries is the development of political systems that can contend with evolving socio-economic realities and open participation to political opposition, argues Carnegie Middle East Program Director Marina Ottaway.

An aggressive policy to promote a true redistribution of power is unlikely to succeed and could prove destabilizing at a time when the next U.S. president will already face crisis conditions in Iraq and Palestine, a defiant Iran, an unstable Lebanon, and high oil prices. In this policy brief, Democracy Promotion in the Middle East: Restoring Credibility, Ottaway argues that the United States can, however, still play a useful role in encouraging reforms.

Future U.S. democracy promotion efforts should:
• Draw a clear distinction between regime change and democracy promotion
• Set modest goals for a limited number of countries and pursue them quietly but transparently
• Consult with and listen to countries from the region before  deciding which changes to encourage and  support
• Affirm the United States’ intention to talk with all political and civil society actors—not as a sign of support or legitimacy, but as a reflection of the need for better understanding.

Ottaway concludes:

“Although the steps advocated here represent a retreat from the flamboyant rhetoric of the recent past, they are not a retreat from the promotion of political reform, which requires not words but consistent action. Democracy promotion in the Middle East has led to no positive results, while undermining U.S. credibility across the region. Neither incumbent regimes nor reform advocates believe any longer that the United States is seeking the democratic transformation of the region. Credibility will not be restored by new rhetoric but by consistent efforts to promote attainable goals.”

 


Posted in  
Add Comment Send to Friend Print
Related Articles
EVENT on "Islamist Parties and Democracy"
Do Muslims deserve democracy?
Testimony on the United States and the Promotion of Human Rights and Democracy
Survey: Gulf Between Democracy in Theory and Practice
Political parties are the second face of democracy
Ellison spreads word in Egypt about benefits of U.S.-style democracy
Political Islam and Democracy - What do Islamists and Islamic Movements want?
Missing in Action: The Democracy Agenda in the Middle East
Democracy – Egyptian Style
No Democracy in the Arab World
Why Middle East democracy is inevitable
Democracy, Presidential Election and the Lobby
In Egypt, democracy is the only solution
Is Islam Compatible with Democracy?
Democracy – Egyptian Style
What’s Left of Bush’s Democracy Agenda?
Selling Democracy - De Lux Model with Double-Standards Built In
Habib Urges Arab Leaders to Embrace Democracy in Pursuit of Stability
Democracy Day in Pakistan Promises No Pardon for Musharraf
MB and democracy, again
Arrest of Muslim Brotherhood supporters illustrates limits to democracy in Egypt
Egyptian-Style Democracy - Or Pakistani?
Pakistan: Time for democracy
Christianity, Islam and the Future of Democracy
Book Review: Islam and Democracy: A Foundation for Ending Extremism and Preventing Conflict (Rash)
What it means... Yemeni Islamists’ stance on democracy
TURKEY - Veiled Democracy?
Political Islam and Democracy - What do Islamists and Islamic Movements want?
Democracy charade undermines rights
Export Security, Not Democracy
Democracy Is a Beautiful Thing
HRW Says Democracy Charade Undermines Rights
Let us not lose faith in democracy
Democracy under siege
Visionary democracy
POMED Notes: Rethinking Democracy Promotion in Middle East at USIP
Democracy Activists Disappointed in Bush
Islam and democracy in Southeast Asia
The Challenge of Democracy
Democracy: fragile seeds that fall on stony ground
Bush Nudges Mideast on Democracy
Islam and democracy The practice—and the theory
Democracy Gets Small Portion of U.S. Aid
Political Islam and The Future of Democracy in the Middle East
MB accepts democracy, regime impedes reform, says Habib
The War on Democracy
Pakistanis Want Larger Role for Both Islam and Democracy
US candidates are vague on Middle East democracy
Democracy: An existential threat ?
Democracy Solves All Problems
Democracy is more than just fair elections -Benazir Bhutto
Reclaiming Democracy
Democracy sidetracked again
Should Democracy Be Promoted or Demoted?
A Different Kind of Democracy
Q&A : Where Is the Democracy in International Relations?
Moderate Islamists and peaceful democracy
Democracy is more than a ballot box
Political Islam and The Future of Democracy in the Middle East
US Must Stand Firm In Support of Democracy and the Rule of Law in Pakistan
Spreading Democracy
Democracy vs. Security
A BBC correspondent’s clever ramble on democracy... Astute analysis of the current political situati
The Tunisian Alternative Can Democracy and Security co-exist in the Middle East?
Close, but No Democracy
Egypt’s Pseudo-Democracy
Support For Democracy Must Be Consistent
The Old Turks’ Revolt: When Radical Secularism Endangers Democracy
UK Conference: Only Solution for Egypt’s Democracy Crisis is MB Participation
Islamism, democracy and political violence in the Arab World: The Hamas challenge
Hamas: Islamic democracy and national liberation
Some election, some democracy!
Promoting Democracy?
Pushback or Progress? Arab Regimes Respond to Democracy’s Challenge
Home Thought on Islam and Democracy
US democracy push makes Middle East liberals cringe
Would Democracy in Morocco be a Good Thing?
Is Spreading Democracy in Middle East a Bad Idea?